Flames Sign Derek Smith
Kent Wilson
July 13 2011 02:44PM

The Fan960 via twitter reported today that the Calgary Flames have inked 27-year old defender Derek Smith, formerly of the Ottawa Senators organization. Smith appeared in nine games for the Sens last year, garnering one assist. The deal is reportedly two-way, with an NHL salary of $700k.
I have to say I am somewhat confused by the addition. Smith joins a depth chart absolutely bursting with similar 'tweener type players. After obvious NHLers like Giordano, Bouwmeester, Sarich and Babchuk, the Flames now boast Chris Butler, Brett Carson, Brendan Mikkelson (RFA), TJ Brodie, Clay Wilson, John Negrin, Chris Breen, Joe Piskula, Jordan Henry and now Smith. That is no less than 10 (!!) defenders signed to two-way deals who might be, at best, 5th-7th defenders in the NHL at this point in their careers (most at the 7th or below end of the scale). I understand the Abbotsford Heat could use some veteran depth, but I'm not sure why all of these guys warrant NHL contracts.
The signing is mostly an inconsequential one, of course, so my confusion isn't anything beyond minor puzzlement. It's just...where are they going to put all these defensemen?
I don't get the Feast at all.
This reminds me of my other sporting love, the Kansas City Royals. They have a GM, who's now been in the job for 5 years. And they are still atrocious, because he signs too many crap players for too much money, often to provide "competition". Sound familiar? But we are told it's all Ok, because it's part of a "process" that will all come to fruition in 2010. Or 2011. Now maybe 2012. But 100% certain 2013 if those don't work!
Point is, I don't doubt Featser has some grand plan that he is executing, that we can't see yet. I just have no confidence at all it is any good, and he isn't doing a thing to reassure me.
"I have to say I am somewhat confused by the addition". Thats why your not the GM of the Flames, Kent.
So, you think a blogger on an opinion site shouldn't have an opinion, jacktard?
Is it possible that he forsees issues getting Mikkelson to sign? Im not sure it even matters.
Yep...Really confused by this one as well
Really? My confusion about the addition of a 14th defender to the Flames depth chart? THAT'S the reason I'm not the Flames general manager! Tell me more oh wise sage of the Internets!
@Jarom
It's possible. I was surprised the club bothered to qualify him in the first place - never seemed all that big on Mikkelson when he arrived, preferring to play him as little as possible.
@marcus
Hey Markus! Nice spin, I like it, all those positive waves we cant lose! I hate to sound like a Moriarity here but I think Feasters options are pretty limited & this was pretty well the safest way to go. So yes there is a plan. The wrinkle that keeps going thru my head is what if? What if Brad Richards said yes to the Calgary offer. Then what??? You sign a 31 year old #1 centre to a monster contract knowing you dont have a stanley cup calibre defence & you're in cap hell again. Perhaps you are right, it's simply posturing to players(Iggy), season ticket holders, fans maybe even owners. I'll reserve judgement & cut a lot of slack until the real long term futures game begins with the February trade deadline.
Cheers cappie! It's been hard to watch but its great to see progress. I'm very curious about how they land another top 3 forward over the next 18 months. You know its coming!
Someone will get the job, but don't expect any quantum leaps in development by any of the D down there. Don't get me wrong, competition is good, but if you have to go to these lengths to get a guy like Brodie (just to use a name) to work harder then you have to wonder about their character in the first place.
Also, the problem with this fostering of a competitive environment is that it's being done with past-their-prime-to-develop, marginal-at-best prospects. So exactly who, how much and to what roster spot are we expecting someone to be pushed?
As for trusting in the braintrust, that's not even a valid argument. Do the words "In Sutter We Trust" ring any bells? The world ( especially the sporting world) is full of incompetency at the management levels.
Everyone has an opinion and it takes someone qualified to sort through all of those opinions and make a decision. You're assuming everything is done by some agreed-upon group consensus. The problem with a non-hockey guy in the GM chair is that you have a non-hockey guy making the final decisions based on input from competing sources.
I give Ken King credit for nothing. This is the same rube who allowed Darryl to rise to the position of Dictator.
Feaster is just throwing everything against the wall and hoping something sticks. Which is the problem I have. Something may well indeed stick, but hope is not a way to run an organization. That and the fact that I'm very skeptical regarding the quality of what he's throwing.
Thanks Kevin!
I'd think if they picked up Richards, this year contracts would be buried, and next year they could drop about 10million off the cap with departing UFAs
Only time will tell. I plan to enjoy watching it all unfold I don't know about you wolfpack ;)