Post-Game: Flames Beat Oil, Give Atomic Wedgies, Steal Lunch Money

Taylor McKee
March 23 2014 12:25AM

IMG_20140322_225742_edit

This night of nights, this game of games, is the sweetest of victories for your fightin' Flames as it comes against our perennially pathetic polar ... poo-heads from the North. It's not that the Flames won big, in Edmonton, it's that the game was just so fun to watch for so many different reasons. Including a Taylor Hall/Dallas Eakins "mis-communication" which looked an awful lot like a cat fight. 

The Flames turned the second period into a highlight package and scored EIGHT TIMES. IN ONE GAME. AGAINST THE OILERS. One of them by Kevin Westgarth, the Brick Tamland of hockey. Drink it in Flames fans, this game is ties the largest margin of victory in a BOA and this may have been the most unexpected of Flames big wins in Edmonton. We can worry about the draft lottery and tanking and the rebuild tomorrow. For right now, this feels great.   

Best game ever.

Also, Matt Stajan melted some hearts with a penalty shot goal, Read all about it after the jump  

GAME SUMMARY


Right off the bat, Kevin Westgarth, whom was dressed tonight for reasons I do not understand, took a roughing penalty two minutes into the game. On that power-play, Jeff Petry scored on a point shot with Ryan Jones parked directly in front of him without a stick. Though the difference between Jones with a stick and without a stick are frankly negligible.  

After the 1-0 goal, Westgarth decided to correct his error by fighting Luke Gadzic, the same guy who knocked him out in a scary incident. Westgarth tried to protect himself throughout the majority of the scrap and was able to hold his own for the most part. Basically, who cares? Westgarth fighting a fellow goon seems inconsequential to me but that hardly seems important now doesn't it? I won't complain about anything else from this point on I promise.

Because after that, things were all smiles in Flameland. T.J Brodie, who rules, started a breakout and the puck found Mark Giordano who absolutely blasted one past Fasth and tied the game at 1. The game was tied at one heading into the second period. All things considered, the game was quite even going into the room, the Flames were leading in shots 9-8.

The second period started off pretty good for the Flames when four and a half minutes in, Paul Byron forced a turnover to Mikael Backlund who found a wide-open red-hot Mike Cammalleri to give the Flames a 2-1 lead. Things got very good after that.

One minute later, Matt Stajan was the recipient of a fairly generous call and was awarded a penalty shot. I wasn't expecting a whole lot from Stajan, whom isn't known as much of a shootout specialist, I think anyone who saw what happened were pretty pleased:   

A pretty emotional goal considering all the hardship that Stajan and his family have endured recently. He points to the sky after the goal and ...yeah. That is a pretty cool moment. Good on him.

The Flames would score twice more before the second period ended, one from Lord Byron, who rules, and one from Glencross who roofed one on Fasth and ended his night. The Flames went into the third WINNING 5-1?! I was tingling with glee. 

Heading into the third, I am sure most Flames fans would have been content with sitting on the four goal lead. However, the Flames decided to reward us for our loyalty this year by laying into our northern foes for three more goals on Ben Scrivens who must be super glad he willingly signed up for another tour of duty in goaltending Vietnam. 

Glencross scored twice in the third to complete the hat-trick and even, sigh, Kevin Westgarth scored in the third off of what I am going to assume was an intentional chest pass from Tyler Wotherspoon to make it 7-1 at that point. The game ended 8-1 and all is good in the world. 

THE RED WARRIOR


One may be tempted to make Ryan Smyth the Red Warrior tonight as he somehow, and I have no idea how, managed to be even in an 8-1 loss. That is amazing. How is that even possible? Anywho, enough of the report from Shelbyville. The Flames had a number of amazing performances tonight including Curtis Glencross who scored a friggen hat trick, Mark Giordano who seems to be on a one man mission to make Dan Hamhuis pay for not being picked for the Olympic team, and T.J Brodie who, along with Gio, was +5 tonight. Even though we all hate that stat, that's still pretty impressive.

However, the obvious choice is good ol' Matthew "Ragin Franchise" Stajan who had four points tonight to go with his penalty shot goal. Just great stuff all around.

SCORING CHANCES

Team Period Time Note Home Away State
Home 1 14:00 Perron 4 19 21 35 57 89 5 7 18 20 24 31 5v5
Away 1 11:19 Agostino 5 14 35 51 84 93 4 8 23 31 44 51 5v5
Home 1 7:52 Schultz 14 19 21 35 51 93 5 18 20 24 31 44 5v5
Home 1 6:50 Hendricks 2 23 27 35 68 85 3 11 13 31 32 56 5v5
Home 1 5:36 Hall 4 5 35 57 84 89 5 7 8 18 20 31 5v5
Away 1 5:08 Colborne 14 19 21 35 51 93 4 8 23 31 44 51 5v5
Away 1 3:08 Monahan 5 21 35 93 94 4 5 11 13 23 31 4v5
Away 1 2:45 Giordano 5 21 35 93 94 4 5 11 13 23 31 4v5
Home 2 17:33 Smyth 2 14 35 51 93 94 3 13 31 32 44 5v4
Away 2 16:41 Glencross 2 27 35 51 68 85 4 7 11 20 24 31 5v5
Away 2 16:18 Monahan 2 27 35 51 68 85 3 8 23 31 51 56 5v5
Away 2 15:48 Cammalleri goal 19 21 23 27 35 68 5 7 11 13 31 32 5v5
Away 2 14:40 Stajan PS goal 2 4 35 57 85 89 5 7 11 13 31 32 5v5
Away 2 14:01 Byron goal 2 4 35 57 85 89 5 7 11 13 31 32 5v5
Home 2 13:06 Lander 5 14 35 51 84 93 4 15 16 17 31 44 5v5
Home 2 11:50 Lander 14 19 21 30 51 93 4 8 23 31 44 51 5v5
Home 2 10:12 Jones 5 20 28 30 84 94 3 15 16 17 31 56 5v5
Away 2 5:34 Hudler 2 30 85 93 94 4 5 8 20 24 31 4v5
Home 2 3:49 Nugent-Hopkins 2 5 14 21 30 93 5 7 17 23 31 51 5v5
Away 2 2:59 Glencross 19 30 51 57 84 89 3 5 18 20 24 31 5v5
Home 3 19:26 Nugent-Hopkins 14 19 30 85 93 5 7 11 31 32 4v4
Away 3 15:16 Glencross 14 19 20 21 30 93 4 18 20 24 31 44 5v5
Away 3 15:11 Glencross goal 14 19 20 21 30 93 4 18 20 24 31 44 5v5
Away 3 14:44 Bouma 5 23 27 28 30 84 3 15 16 17 31 56 5v5
Away 3 14:34 Westgarth goal 5 23 27 28 30 84 3 15 16 17 31 56 5v5
Away 3 13:47 Cammalleri 2 20 30 57 85 89 4 8 13 23 31 44 5v5
Home 3 10:10 Smyth 19 20 21 28 30 94 4 15 16 17 31 44 5v5
Away 3 7:06 Glencross 19 20 21 28 30 94 4 18 20 24 31 44 5v5
Home 3 6:57 Gazdic 5 20 30 57 84 94 4 18 20 24 31 44 5v5
Away 3 4:50 Monahan 4 14 19 21 30 93 4 8 23 31 44 51 5v5
Away 3 3:45 Bouma 5 20 28 30 84 94 3 15 16 17 31 44 5v5
Away 3 3:30 Agostino 19 21 30 51 57 89 4 16 23 31 44 51 5v5
# Player EV PP SH
3 SMID, LADISLAV 19:30 5 2 00:00 0 0 01:12 0 1
4 RUSSELL, KRIS 18:20 9 4 03:45 3 0 00:01 0 0
5 GIORDANO, MARK 13:15 4 5 04:19 3 0 02:13 0 0
7 BRODIE, TJ 16:30 4 4 01:56 0 0 00:40 0 0
8 COLBORNE, JOE 15:05 5 2 02:04 1 0 00:00 0 0
11 BACKLUND, MIKAEL 13:00 4 2 03:22 2 0 00:39 0 0
13 CAMMALLERI, MIKE 13:08 4 1 03:22 2 0 00:33 0 1
15 WESTGARTH, KEVIN 10:05 3 3 00:00 0 0 00:00 0 0
16 MCGRATTAN, BRIAN 11:13 4 3 00:00 0 0 00:00 0 0
17 BOUMA, LANCE 13:17 3 4 00:15 0 0 02:15 0 0
18 STAJAN, MATT 09:39 4 4 00:00 0 0 02:09 0 0
20 GLENCROSS, CURTIS 10:28 5 4 02:04 1 0 00:01 0 0
23 MONAHAN, SEAN 17:26 6 2 03:24 2 0 00:04 0 0
24 HUDLER, JIRI 10:11 5 3 02:17 1 0 00:01 0 0
31 RAMO, KARRI   17 11   3 0   0 1
32 BYRON, PAUL 13:32 3 2 00:00 0 0 01:10 0 1
44 BUTLER, CHRIS 17:07 9 5 01:22 0 0 02:46 0 1
51 AGOSTINO, KENNY 13:17 5 2 00:15 0 0 00:00 0 0
56 WOTHERSPOON, TYLER 17:04 3 2 00:00 0 0 00:00 0 0
Period Totals EV PP 5v3 PP SH 5v3 SH
1 4 4 2 4 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
2 7 5 6 4 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0
3 9 3 9 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

SUM IT UP


Flames rule, while the Oilers a pathetic excuse for a joke... also, they drool.

Flames host the Sharks on Monday.

112039ec99211abeba03b81d364735ec
Taylor splits time between UVIC and Calgary studying history. Taylor likes the Flames, the Cannons, Buckshot, and the Oxford comma. Taylor scored on his own net on dome ice when he was 8. Twitter: @TaylorMcKee_
Avatar
#1 Beloch and Shart
March 23 2014, 01:08AM
Trash it!
33
trashes
Props
4
props

How come McGrattan never yaps at Sabres players during the warm up or stares down the Sabres bench?

Avatar
#2 Kent Wilson
March 23 2014, 03:53PM
Trash it!
28
trashes
Props
20
props

@hockeydoofus

Take the fallacious arguments elsewhere please. They don't aid discussion in the least.

Avatar
#3 hockeydoofus
March 23 2014, 03:26PM
Trash it!
18
trashes
Props
14
props

@TheoForever

For all you guys that criticize McGratten, Westgarth, etc., how many NHL games have you played, how many NHL goals have you scored and how many NHL heavyweights have you fought. Yea, right.

Avatar
#4 dotfras
March 23 2014, 11:03AM
Trash it!
17
trashes
Props
10
props

Monahan Colborne Agostino with a goose egg in an 8-1 is a little disappointing.

Avatar
#5 Primo
March 23 2014, 01:16AM
Trash it!
16
trashes
Props
5
props
Beloch and Shart wrote:

How come McGrattan never yaps at Sabres players during the warm up or stares down the Sabres bench?

Does the answer have something to do with Big John SCOTT???

Avatar
#6 Chambers
March 23 2014, 10:31AM
Trash it!
15
trashes
Props
18
props

I also suspect the writer has never played the game before. Westgarth and Gratts bring toughness and send the opposition a message as early as the pre game lineup review!

You can't have 12 pretty boys playing forward trying to score goals. It doesn't work that way Taylor!

Avatar
#7 beloch
March 23 2014, 01:05AM
Trash it!
11
trashes
Props
36
props

Sometimes, nothing will do but a Conan quote. An old-school Conan quote.

What is best in life?

To crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and to hear the lamentation of their women.

Tonight, the killer instinct was there. The Flames had Edmonton's throats under their boots and they pressed down without mercy or compassion for almost two full periods. It was glorious!

Gazdic again proved that he has zero class by fighting with his visor on. Westgarth's hands were a bloody mess from connecting with Gazdic's visor over and over again. Hopefully the enforcers of the league will clue in and start giving Gazdic the cold-shoulder (and lopsided time in the box) when he tries to start stuff. This is a player who does not follow the code.

Hall and Eakins did effective damage control in their post-game interviews, but the writing is on the wall. Eakins is toast. The $6M club stopped paying attention to him half a season ago. After, what, five coaches in as many years, it's pretty clear who runs the Oilers.

It was great to see the return of scoreface, but Matt Stajan's 4 point triumph tonight was the sweetest thing of all. In this dark hour of his grief, the man deserves a little light. #$%@ yeah Matt Stajan. #$%@ yeah.

Avatar
#8 suba steve
March 23 2014, 12:02PM
Trash it!
11
trashes
Props
7
props
Baalzamon wrote:

wasn't for lack of effort/quality play. They combined for 11 shots on goal (better than one third of the Flames' total) and none of them had worse than a +3 scoring chance count. They were all above 60% Corsi (and Fenwick) too, and that's with score effects working against them.

When are they gonna finally start giving points (in the standings) for positive Corsi results and scoring chance count (and Fenwick). Stupid NHL.

Avatar
#9 TheoForever
March 23 2014, 10:22AM
Trash it!
8
trashes
Props
25
props

Since the writer doesn't understand, Westgarth played tonight because he is part of our team, just like McGratten, likeable guys, popular with their teammates. They serve their purpose and can play a little as well.

However, it is nice that you established high moral ground, from now on we can all see how enlightened you are.

Don Cherry was great tonight, great comments! Great game by the Flames, love it!

The fact that we have caused meltdowns of both Van and Oil, priceless!

Avatar
#10 Baalzamon
March 23 2014, 04:24PM
Trash it!
7
trashes
Props
10
props
hockeydoofus wrote:

For all you guys that criticize McGratten, Westgarth, etc., how many NHL games have you played, how many NHL goals have you scored and how many NHL heavyweights have you fought. Yea, right.

how many have you?

Avatar
#11 TheoForever
March 23 2014, 03:07PM
Trash it!
6
trashes
Props
15
props

Once in a while someone comes along and starts criticizing enforces and fighting. Those people make empty statements about lack of evidence to support the claim that enforces can change the outcome of a game, which btw. they can and do.

I have been thinking about who those people are and why they think the way they do, and finally I think I understand.

There is a GENERATION GAP.

I'm going to take you back to a time, that once was and has come to an end in places like Canada. A time before lawyers and crybabies. Back to a time where your mommy and daddy didn't drive you around to clubs and events.

A time where kids played in their own neighbourhoods policed themselves on the playgrounds with no adult supervision. Yeah, that time existed not that long ago.

There was 10 of us or so, we were about 12 years old and we were playing soccer. A bunch (6) of 16-17 year olds came around and they took our ball and told us to get lost. We knew them but being younger didn't hang out with them.

One of our group was bigger and more aggressive, he was our leader and best player the driving force in all the games. That day he challenged one of the older boys and fight erupted, he got some licks in but he was loosing. The older boy had him in a headlock, and was telling him to give up but our guy wouldn't. The moment he was realised he kept coming at the older kid. It didn't matter how badly he got hit he would not give up. Finally, the other older boys stepped in and separated the two.

They gave the ball back and left. We stayed on the playground and kept playing.

A few hours later they came back and said -'let's play'. We split into groups to make it fair. From that day on we weren't picked on and not just by those guys but anyone else. We had our protection.

It took one guy's bloodied nose and never give up attitude no matter what.

This brings me back to Westgarth and why Hartley put him in the game. Westgarh had to face his nemesis, because he is a 'gunfighter' and has no choice. Hartley, understands what it is like and he knows what it does for the team. Yeah, Westgarth played a big role in this win.

You can criticize as much as you want but the players felt it and coach knew it.

Cheers

Avatar
#12 mattyc
March 23 2014, 07:13PM
Trash it!
6
trashes
Props
3
props

@suba steve

I would expect a coach to be learning from his past mistakes. I'm skeptical that a cursory attribute like fighting or intimidation outweighs better hockey skills - it just seems like a pretty extraordinary claim. Extraordinary claims need extraordinary proof, and no data (that I've seen/read at least) seems to support this idea in any significant way.

@clyde

I'm actually, all things considered, pretty happy with the job Hartley has done this year. Would I rather have seen Galiardi over Westgarth last night? - yep, 10/10 times I'd bet on Galiardi outperforming Westgarth, but at the end of the day, a guy playing 8 minutes a night isn't going to win you a game very often.

Avatar
#13 Resolute
March 23 2014, 06:51PM
Trash it!
5
trashes
Props
7
props
Kent Wilson wrote:

Take the fallacious arguments elsewhere please. They don't aid discussion in the least.

It added about as much as Taylor's pointless anti-fighting whining in the game story did.

Avatar
#14 Burnward
March 23 2014, 08:34PM
Trash it!
5
trashes
Props
13
props

Re: Westgarth/McGratton

I think last night displayed the differing "identities" of the Flames and Oilers.

We are a hard working, in your face club...and they are soft as hell.

While Big Ern and Westgarth may not have the most skills on the team, they do allow the more skilled players to play their game.

When's the last time a Flame got cheap shotted? The other teams know they have to answer the bell if that happens.

While it's easy to dismiss them...these guys go to war each night and knowing that you have nukes, just in case, probably opens the ice a little bit more.

This team could have been fallen apart at times but instead has grown together.

This isn't about CORSI or any stats, it's about a mentality that a team needs to win in this league.

Avatar
#15 Bull
March 23 2014, 01:13AM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Props
2
props
beloch wrote:

Sometimes, nothing will do but a Conan quote. An old-school Conan quote.

What is best in life?

To crush your enemies, see them driven before you, and to hear the lamentation of their women.

Tonight, the killer instinct was there. The Flames had Edmonton's throats under their boots and they pressed down without mercy or compassion for almost two full periods. It was glorious!

Gazdic again proved that he has zero class by fighting with his visor on. Westgarth's hands were a bloody mess from connecting with Gazdic's visor over and over again. Hopefully the enforcers of the league will clue in and start giving Gazdic the cold-shoulder (and lopsided time in the box) when he tries to start stuff. This is a player who does not follow the code.

Hall and Eakins did effective damage control in their post-game interviews, but the writing is on the wall. Eakins is toast. The $6M club stopped paying attention to him half a season ago. After, what, five coaches in as many years, it's pretty clear who runs the Oilers.

It was great to see the return of scoreface, but Matt Stajan's 4 point triumph tonight was the sweetest thing of all. In this dark hour of his grief, the man deserves a little light. #$%@ yeah Matt Stajan. #$%@ yeah.

Sure!!!

Avatar
#16 Colin.S
March 23 2014, 11:00AM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Props
3
props

Anyone get the sense that unless the Oilers bring in some REAL talent this offseason we are going to see a trade demand/camp holdout from Hall? That guys looks to be about as interested in being there as Heatley was to be traded there.

Anyways back to the Flames, GIO FOR NORRIS!!! But seriously, hope we can find/draft/sign another Dmen to rotate into the top 4 to go along with Russell and Wideman. Because I think we have a decent defence corps, just need to find some two way forwards to go along with it.

Avatar
#17 suba steve
March 23 2014, 04:17PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Props
22
props
Kent Wilson wrote:

Take the fallacious arguments elsewhere please. They don't aid discussion in the least.

So, all the "hockey people" and players who believe that goons are a benefit to their teams...these people are all just 100% wrong? I suppose Gretzky took McSorley with him to LA for the pleasure of his company?

I won't pretend that I know anything for sure, but what I'll say is that the Flames better err on the side of caution with their goon position(s) when Johnny Gaudreau arrives in Calgary. If a goon can possibly make Johnny play a couple of inches taller, well...he needs all the help he can get in that department.

Avatar
#18 Baalzamon
March 23 2014, 04:27PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Props
24
props

How in the name of all that is holy did the ancient, unnecessary, and poorly-fought argument about enforcers erupt in the post-game thread of an 8-1 win over THE OILERS??? Enjoy it. Savour it. Marvel at Westgarth's hand-eye coordination.

Otherwise, everyone just shove it.

Avatar
#19 mattyc
March 23 2014, 05:28PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Props
7
props
suba steve wrote:

So, all the "hockey people" and players who believe that goons are a benefit to their teams...these people are all just 100% wrong? I suppose Gretzky took McSorley with him to LA for the pleasure of his company?

I won't pretend that I know anything for sure, but what I'll say is that the Flames better err on the side of caution with their goon position(s) when Johnny Gaudreau arrives in Calgary. If a goon can possibly make Johnny play a couple of inches taller, well...he needs all the help he can get in that department.

Kevin Lowe is a hockey person, Randy Carlyle is a hockey person, Don Cherry is a hockey person, PJ Stock is a hockey person. The game isn't static - what may have helped in Gretzky's era isn't necessarily important anymore. Rules change, strategies change, the more we drag our feet and try to follow what may have worked 20 years ago, the more we fail to adapt and innovate new (better?) strategies.

Avatar
#20 clyde
March 23 2014, 06:29PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Props
4
props
mattyc wrote:

Kevin Lowe is a hockey person, Randy Carlyle is a hockey person, Don Cherry is a hockey person, PJ Stock is a hockey person. The game isn't static - what may have helped in Gretzky's era isn't necessarily important anymore. Rules change, strategies change, the more we drag our feet and try to follow what may have worked 20 years ago, the more we fail to adapt and innovate new (better?) strategies.

Just because a coach values some things that were valued 20 years ago, doesn't necessarily mean they still don't change and are not creative. Some hockey people like Hartley obviously values guys you think should be out of the game but I also see a coach who values creativity, fitness, speed, compete, a team first mentality and has been and is still a successful coach. Doing the same things as other coaches regardless of personal and talent level because it is working for others would worry me much more.

Avatar
#21 TheoForever
March 23 2014, 10:49PM
Trash it!
4
trashes
Props
3
props

@ Derzie

"The gap you are referring to is an education gap. A few years in school will teach you that bravery is smart, bravado is dumb....."

Life teaches you those lessons, not school.

School if you choose it right, will give you tools to use in life to make a living.

Some people need school and some don't.

Avatar
#22 mtgould89
March 23 2014, 12:28AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
36
props

Instead of "Oil Change", Sportsnet should start airing a show called "Imminent Oil Management Change".

Avatar
#23 CTibs
March 23 2014, 12:32AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
41
props

I will never apologize for the schadenfreude I felt when I saw another Oilers jersey thrown onto the ice. Tonight was glorious.

Avatar
#24 lionlager
March 23 2014, 12:55AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
26
props

Giving the gm job to a guy who wouldn't play with a helmet is obviously a smart plan. He makes the shrewd moves the Oilers need, like bringing in an ex flame and making him captain.

Great game. Man, it's kind of sad to see how little progress they've made up there after all these years. But it's also funny. Real funny.

Avatar
#25 herringchoker
March 23 2014, 06:32AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
9
props

Hey Guys, I was at the Halifax mooseheads games this weekend and had a good look at Nik Ehlers. Kid is awesome. Looks like Drouins clone. Kid was dangerous every time he touched the puck and man can he skate. He's not afraid to go to net and has very soft hands. He is the real deal. He will be the sleeper in this draft.

Avatar
#26 Jeff In Lethbridge
March 23 2014, 09:09AM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
23
props

is it right to enjoy this win so much? Yes, the boys took the lunch-money from the odd, handicapped kid, but in this case they deserved it.

As for Gazdik, time for a new rule; 2 for taking your helmet off, or 4 for leaving it on. lol

Cherry can be brash and obnoxious but he is (in my opinion) right in this case.

If Gazdik is going to be a tough guy, an enforcer, he cannot wear equipment that makes it impossible for the other party to fight back without hurting himself. Cowardly and dishonorable. and then To sit there and laugh in the penalty box because Wesgarth's hands were all torn up is pathetic.

Avatar
#27 Jibmeister
March 23 2014, 12:29PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
25
props

As much as everyone hates Westgarth, that tip of his was actually extremely nice.

Avatar
#28 Clyde
March 23 2014, 12:48PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
16
props
Jibmeister wrote:

As much as everyone hates Westgarth, that tip of his was actually extremely nice.

Westgarth plays his role given to him well. He is energetic, physical and courageous. He never takes a shift off and he showed last night that he will do what it takes to fulfill his role no matter what. That rubs off on younger players and they see what needs to be done to fulfill their roles as well. Not everyone on here hates him. As was said in an earlier comment, it takes all kinds of players to build a team

Avatar
#29 hockeydoofus
March 23 2014, 06:54PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
5
props

@Baalzamon

None at all. I just don't criticize those that can do all three.

Avatar
#30 clyde
March 23 2014, 09:50PM
Trash it!
3
trashes
Props
8
props
mattyc wrote:

I do like what Hartley did from a personal perspective (giving Westgarth a chance to come back from a brutal showing - and probably an embarrassing or at least sobering incident as a fighter). But from a utility perspective, I'm not sure it's a better way to win a hockey game, but I'm sympathetic to the argument that people are more important than a throwaway game against the oilers when both teams are already booking tee times.

Regarding measurement: You can't directly measure the impact of a fight, but if it has any meaningful impact on the game, and improves player performance, it would show in other statistics that measure player performance. For instance if we work on the premise that every flames player played harder after the fight, and playing harder made the flames more likely to win the game, you could create a testable hypothesis to see if any measure of success (corsi, goals, whatever your flavour) improved after the fight.

Personally, I'm skeptical.

1. I feel like the Flames were probably giving their all already (or if they weren't, the difference before/after would be insignificantly small)

2. Even if there were a difference, I'm skeptical it would be greater than the difference between a 5min/night enforcer and a functional 3-4th liner.

I understand your skepticism. But, keep an open mind. There are things in this game that simply cannot be explained or measured.

Avatar
#31 beloch
March 23 2014, 01:28AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
9
props

@Beloch and Shart

Heh. I thought you were a troll from Vancouver. Shocking!

Avatar
#32 Skuehler
March 23 2014, 01:45AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
39
props

Can't help but feel the Calgary Vancouver game from a few months back where Torts lost his mind was a turning point for the Nucks. They're demise has been imminent from that point on. Maybe we see something similar here where while the Soilers have been awful for a while, perhaps it's this embarrassment that is a catalyst for change.

Flames haven't won a lot on the score sheet this year but they have sure caused grief for their two main rivals. And those are moral victories.

Avatar
#33 Fire It Up
March 23 2014, 02:26AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
6
props

If you ever want to read a great book, I managed to dust off my old draft. Thinking about submitting it to a publisher.

http://i.gyazo.com/b9a0ab928242ce81fe63de6faf6caffe.png

Avatar
#34 P. Ennis
March 23 2014, 09:12AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
24
props

The poor Oilers are enduring a rebuild inside a rebuild inside what will soon be another rebuild. A rebuild inception.

Avatar
#35 theartfuldodger
March 23 2014, 09:55AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
8
props

Goaltenders vietnam.........lol!

Avatar
#36 BurningSensation
March 23 2014, 11:31AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
15
props
dotfras wrote:

Monahan Colborne Agostino with a goose egg in an 8-1 is a little disappointing.

You have to work pretty hard to find a sour note in last nights game, and I guess that would have to be it.

Avatar
#37 Baalzamon
March 23 2014, 11:49AM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
6
props

@dotfras

wasn't for lack of effort/quality play. They combined for 11 shots on goal (better than one third of the Flames' total) and none of them had worse than a +3 scoring chance count. They were all above 60% Corsi (and Fenwick) too, and that's with score effects working against them.

Avatar
#38 beloch
March 23 2014, 04:08PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
10
props
TheoForever wrote:

Once in a while someone comes along and starts criticizing enforces and fighting. Those people make empty statements about lack of evidence to support the claim that enforces can change the outcome of a game, which btw. they can and do.

I have been thinking about who those people are and why they think the way they do, and finally I think I understand.

There is a GENERATION GAP.

I'm going to take you back to a time, that once was and has come to an end in places like Canada. A time before lawyers and crybabies. Back to a time where your mommy and daddy didn't drive you around to clubs and events.

A time where kids played in their own neighbourhoods policed themselves on the playgrounds with no adult supervision. Yeah, that time existed not that long ago.

There was 10 of us or so, we were about 12 years old and we were playing soccer. A bunch (6) of 16-17 year olds came around and they took our ball and told us to get lost. We knew them but being younger didn't hang out with them.

One of our group was bigger and more aggressive, he was our leader and best player the driving force in all the games. That day he challenged one of the older boys and fight erupted, he got some licks in but he was loosing. The older boy had him in a headlock, and was telling him to give up but our guy wouldn't. The moment he was realised he kept coming at the older kid. It didn't matter how badly he got hit he would not give up. Finally, the other older boys stepped in and separated the two.

They gave the ball back and left. We stayed on the playground and kept playing.

A few hours later they came back and said -'let's play'. We split into groups to make it fair. From that day on we weren't picked on and not just by those guys but anyone else. We had our protection.

It took one guy's bloodied nose and never give up attitude no matter what.

This brings me back to Westgarth and why Hartley put him in the game. Westgarh had to face his nemesis, because he is a 'gunfighter' and has no choice. Hartley, understands what it is like and he knows what it does for the team. Yeah, Westgarth played a big role in this win.

You can criticize as much as you want but the players felt it and coach knew it.

Cheers

There's also a bit of a disconnect between people who played nothing but refereed ice hockey and never ball-hockey or shinny. Things do get out of hand easier when there's no box or higher authority. In the NHL the players are so big and passionate that the referees and box aren't always enough to maintain control. What you've described is a valid reason to employ and deploy the big guys.

There are subtleties to the debate over enforcers however. Something else is going on when prearranged goon fights happen the moment the puck first hits the ice. There's nothing about sticking up for team-mates or preventing nastiness going on there. It's just a circus side-show to get the crowd cheering. Those fights are an embarrassment to the league and pose needless risk of injury to the enforcers themselves. The question is, how do you rewrite the rules to cut out the meaningless fights without removing the meaningful ones?

Although changing the rules on the ice remains a conundrum, one thing I would like to see is a little less gladiatorial pomp in arenas when fights happen. Even in hitmen games where it's just kids that are playing, fights break out frequently. When they do, on come the flashing lights and heavy-metal music. The crowd is encouraged to cheer and jeer. I'm surprised they don't have the ice-crew come on and start throwing loaves of bread into the stands! It's repugnant. Leave the lights the way they are. Don't turn on the music. Treat it like two kids are out there risking injury or death.

Avatar
#39 suba steve
March 23 2014, 06:12PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
3
props
mattyc wrote:

Kevin Lowe is a hockey person, Randy Carlyle is a hockey person, Don Cherry is a hockey person, PJ Stock is a hockey person. The game isn't static - what may have helped in Gretzky's era isn't necessarily important anymore. Rules change, strategies change, the more we drag our feet and try to follow what may have worked 20 years ago, the more we fail to adapt and innovate new (better?) strategies.

Failing to change with the times is not smart, I'll grant you that, but what would you call failing to learn from the past?

Avatar
#40 mattyc
March 23 2014, 08:38PM
Trash it!
2
trashes
Props
6
props

@Clyde

I do like what Hartley did from a personal perspective (giving Westgarth a chance to come back from a brutal showing - and probably an embarrassing or at least sobering incident as a fighter). But from a utility perspective, I'm not sure it's a better way to win a hockey game, but I'm sympathetic to the argument that people are more important than a throwaway game against the oilers when both teams are already booking tee times.

Regarding measurement: You can't directly measure the impact of a fight, but if it has any meaningful impact on the game, and improves player performance, it would show in other statistics that measure player performance. For instance if we work on the premise that every flames player played harder after the fight, and playing harder made the flames more likely to win the game, you could create a testable hypothesis to see if any measure of success (corsi, goals, whatever your flavour) improved after the fight.

Personally, I'm skeptical.

1. I feel like the Flames were probably giving their all already (or if they weren't, the difference before/after would be insignificantly small)

2. Even if there were a difference, I'm skeptical it would be greater than the difference between a 5min/night enforcer and a functional 3-4th liner.

Avatar
#41 Ryan Pike
March 23 2014, 12:32AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
63
props

They truly are building something special up there.

Avatar
#43 bs
March 23 2014, 08:02AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
4
props
beloch wrote:

Heh. I thought you were a troll from Vancouver. Shocking!

I am!

Avatar
#44 SmellOfVictory
March 23 2014, 08:37AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
13
props
CTibs wrote:

I will never apologize for the schadenfreude I felt when I saw another Oilers jersey thrown onto the ice. Tonight was glorious.

As bad as I feel for Oilers fans, I do think it's pretty funny that jersey throwing is becoming a tradition up there.

Avatar
#45 TRAV
March 23 2014, 08:37AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
50
props

I appreciate that we are near the bottom of the standings so I say this with some temper... Jay Feaster deserves some credit.

1. Hartley has proven to be the right coach for this group getting the most out of his team and getting them to learn good habits and play the right way.

2. Ramo is looking more and more like the future goalie of this team. A shrewd move to include him in the trade.

3. While the trade wasn't a good one Byron is emerging as a quality player.

4. Colborne is looking like a great return for a fourth. Starting to dominate along the boards and showing some signs of being a quality two way player.

5. Our farm system is better than it has been in a number of years. Ward is doing an amazing job of teaching the kids the right way to play and you can see that the organization as a whole is connected in philosophy. Players like Knight, Wotherspoon, Byron, Ortio, Street, Granlund, are showing signs of promise and proper development.

6.Monhan. Right player to draft, right time and right decision to keep him up. He is going to score 20 as a rookie.

7.. Jankowski is looking like the best player to be drafted in that year... Well wait... okay maybe not yet....but he is improving.

While Feaster made a number of well documented mistakes I think that it is also worthwhile to recognize that he is the one responsible for setting the Flames on the right path. It's still a long, long path but we are clearly headed in the right direction.

Avatar
#46 RexLibris
March 23 2014, 09:01AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
48
props

I've been sent here to ask for our team's asses back...if its alright with you guys.

:)

Avatar
#47 dotfras
March 23 2014, 09:09AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
8
props

@TRAV

Agree with all, however I think the Colborne move would be majorly credited to BB.

It's been nice to watch the Flames create their own route through the course of this rebuild. There has been a ton of growth over the last two years. While we may never see a first overall pick, management has done a pretty good job righting the ship.

I'd say our greatest needs to address over the summer are a 1G & a Second Pairing D Man.

Avatar
#48 Jeff In Lethbridge
March 23 2014, 09:15AM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
13
props
Beloch and Shart wrote:

How come McGrattan never yaps at Sabres players during the warm up or stares down the Sabres bench?

why, is he supposed to?

Avatar
#49 Baalzamon
March 23 2014, 12:00PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
22
props

Looking at the icetime allocation last night--and it's straight-up insulting to the Oilers.

  • McGrattan and Westgarth both played more than 10 minutes
  • Stajan, Glencross, and Hudler all had less icetime than Agostino
  • Sean Monahan led the Flames' forwards with ~21 minutes
  • Giordano and Brodie both played less than 20 minutes
  • Backlund and Cammalleri both had less icetime than Tyler Wotherspoon
Avatar
#50 TheoForever
March 23 2014, 12:43PM
Trash it!
1
trashes
Props
15
props

@Jibmeister

Not everyone hates Westgarth. Not everyone hates Butler. Who btw. has shown a great improvement and deserves another contract.

The coaching done in Calgary and Abby has been very good. Clearly those guys are good teachers.

Comments are closed for this article.