What went wrong with CalgaryNEXT?

Kent Wilson
April 25 2016 08:00AM

With the City of Calgary officially calling the CalgaryNEXT proposal untenable, the Flames sports district project as it is currently envisioned seems dead in the water. What's more, this outcome seemed inevitable given how completely CSEC had lost the PR war in the period between their campaign launch and the city's rebuttal.

Regular readers here know I am fundamentally opposed to the public subsidizing major arena projects like this one, because the economics and risk associated them always overtly favour the team and not the taxpayer. Aside from flagrantly transgressing the principle of public dollars for public benefit, the CalgaryNEXT pitch had three fatal flaws that ultimately doomed it:

  1. It didn't properly consider the city's perspective.
  2. It didn't sell a comprehensive or inspiring vision.
  3. It suffered from bad timing and poor political optics.

Let's investigate each of these in more depth.

Read Article | 52 Comments

How good is Mark Giordano?

Kent Wilson
April 23 2016 02:00PM

Few NHL players have taken a longer and more winding road than Mark Giordano. The Flames captain was undrafted in junior, undrafted in the NHL and played a year in Russia as a 25-year-old. That's the resume of untold numbers of failed pro hockey players - guys who dominated their house and high school leagues but could never quite make it over the hump. Indeed when Gio fled for Europe during his contract dispute, many figured it was the last any of us would see of him on NHL ice.

Not so much. 

Read Article | 31 Comments

Should the Flames look into Calvin Pickard?

Ari Yanover
April 23 2016 08:00AM

This past off-season, a fair number of goalies changed teams. Some of these trades worked out, while some appeared to be more of the footnote variety.

While some teams acquired back-ups, though, around the time of the draft and before free agency, three teams got goalies who projected to be starters:

  • The Buffalo Sabres traded a first round pick (21st overall) for David Legwand and Robin Lehner. 
  • The Edmonton Oilers traded three picks for Cam Talbot (and another pick).
  • The San Jose Sharks traded their 2016 first round pick and a prospect for Martin Jones.

Lehner ended up spending a fair amount of the season on the shelf. Talbot's numbers dropped, but remained respectable enough as he nearly doubled his NHL games played (57 with the Rangers; 56 with the Oilers) and ultimately won the starter's job in Edmonton. And Jones went on to 65 games with the Sharks in a single season as their starter (with a .918 SV% on a team that's won at least one playoff round).

Three teams got creative to solve their goaltending woes, and while the jury is still out on two of them, the Sharks appear to have made a successful gamble with a 26-year-old goalie that had only played 34 NHL games before getting traded. In him, they found their starter.

So... how about Calvin Pickard?

Read Article | 35 Comments

FN Offseason Plans

Kent Wilson
April 22 2016 02:00PM

Brad Treliving and the Calgary Flames no doubt have some big summer plans: find a goalie, get rid of some deadweight and draft in the top three (fingers crossed) to say the least. FlamesNation plans to be there when all that happens, of course, but we have a collection of other series and projects up our sleeves as well. 

Here's an overview of what we're planning. Take a look and let us know what you think. 

Read Article | 30 Comments

What are realistic expectations for Daniel Pribyl?

Pat Steinberg
April 22 2016 10:00AM

pribyl_daniel

With Calgary's soon to be confirmed signing of Czech product Daniel Pribyl, many of us have become very curious about the 23-year-old winger. Just what are the Flames getting in the former sixth round pick of the Habs? At this point, no one knows for sure how Pribyl might translate to the NHL, but we do have some recent examples to compare him to. As I see it, this could go one of three ways.

Read Article | 30 Comments