The Zdeno Chara hit has sent the country, okay, mainly a few politicians, an airline, an entire province and now the Police, into a frenzy. It was seven years ago this past Tuesday that Todd Bertuzzi jumped Steve Moore and the reaction wasn’t close to the emotional outcry that we are witnessing right now.

First it was the politicians trying to gain popularity. via the Toronto Sun:

"I simply don’t understand what the NHL is thinking here," Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff told reporters after the NHL made its decision. "It’s up to the National Hockey League to protect its players. It’s up to the National Hockey League to protect all the young kids playing the game. It’s up to the National Hockey League to act and I can tell you, there is strong feeling in the House of Commons that if they don’t act, then, you know, we should get involved. No politician wants to get involved in this, it’s not our business. But as a citizens, as a fan, I think it’s outrageous."

The Chara hit came up during daily Question Period in the House of Commons minutes before the NHL released its decision.

NDP MP Glenn Thibeault, who has been pushing new legislation to reduce concussions and other serious injuries in amateur sports, told the House the Chara hit was more evidence new rules are needed.

Minister of State for Sport Gary Lunn said the government had been consulting with national sporting organizations on the issue.

"It is something that we hope that the NHL also takes very seriously. This type of hitting is unacceptable," Lunn said. "We would do everything to ensure that NHL does not allow this kind of action to continue."

I’m sure all of us are happy that the Liberals, NDP and Conservatives are so concerned about the game. I’m not sure what new rule Thibeault would like put in, but based on their track record I’m sure they will follow up with a comprehensive study and actually try and do something to lessen concussions.

Or they might put as much work into reducing concussions as they have into making our criminal system more fair.


Then Air Canada sent a letter to Gary Bettman. Here is a portion of  it.

"We are contacting you (Wednesday) to voice our concern over (Tuesday night’s) incident involving Max Pacioretty and Zdeno Chara at the Bell Centre in Montreal," wrote Vandal. "This is following several other incidents involving career-threatening and life-threatening headshots in the NHL recently."

Vandal noted the controversial issue is becoming bad for Air Canada’s brand.

"From a corporate social responsibility standpoint, it is becoming increasingly difficult to associate our brand with sports events which could lead to serious and irresponsible accidents; action must be taken by the NHL before we are encountered with a fatality.

"Unless the NHL takes immediate action with serious suspension to the players in question to curtail these life-threatening injuries, Air Canada will withdraw its sponsorship of hockey."

Not only does Air Canada own the naming rights to Toronto’s Air Canada Centre, it’s believed they’re a major corporate sponsor behind all six Canadian teams. Air Canada’s head office is also located in Montreal.

Call me skeptical, but I wonder how much of this letter had to do with their head office being in Montreal, compared to the backlash of fans/flyers who choose West Jet because they aren’t a major NHL sponsor? I might be naive in thinking that this is another case of head office pandering to the rationale and bias-free Montrealers.


Finally the Montreal Police got involved (via TSN)

Law enforcement got involved following a request by Quebec’s director of criminal and penal prosecutions, Louis Dionne.

A spokeswoman for Dionne said that, after seeing television footage of the incident, he issued a recommendation to the provincial Public Security department that an investigation be opened.

The department then forwarded the file to police.

"The police investigation will be held. Like all police investigations, evidence will be gathered and an investigation report will be submitted (to the DCPP)," said spokeswoman Martine Berube.

"(The DCPP) will then evaluate to see whether there’s grounds for prosecution."

Asked what kind of punishment could be assessed in a case like Chara’s, she replied: "It’s too early to say. That would depend on what charges are laid. That’s a little difficult to predict at this point."

The move came amid a burst of outrage after the National Hockey League declined to suspend Chara.

Earlier Wednesday, Dionne’s own office downplayed talk of a criminal investigation but hardened its tone hours later when the league announced no sanctions would be taken.  

I wonder if the Police in Montreal would have investigated this hit if it was a Boston Bruin on the receiving end? I’m sure the police would have been inundated with calls from Montreal fans livid that an innocent Bruins player was so maliciously attacked on the ice.

To me this is clearly a case where passion and biased emotion has taken charge. Politicians, Air Canada and the Quebec police are pandering to the highly emotional Canadien fans. I will be very surprised if any of these three factions follow through on their threats. Sure there will be an investigation, but I don’t see any charges coming.

Air Canada has made their point with their Montreal flyers and I don’t see them pulling their sponsorship, while the politicians will jump on the next hot topic very quickly and we won’t hear from them until another borderline hockey hit, where a Canadian-based team has one of their players injured.


Check out this Jack Johnson hit on Ryan Smyth. 

One of the biggest arguments/complaints surrounding the Chara hit is that he knew where the "turnbuckle" was and deliberately drove Max Parioretty’s head into it. Did Johnson do the same thing here? Outside of Don Cherry showing it on CBC was it ever talked about as much as the Chara hit?

I know Smyth had the puck, but many of the Chara haters suggested his hit was intentional, so was Johnson who was facing the "turnbuckle" just as guilty?

I love hockey, and I love how passionate Canadians are about the game, but in this case too many people have overreacted and have made it more personal than rationale.

That is disappointing. 

  • Reality Check to the head

    The League made the right decision. People should punish the people who designed the rink, not the player.

    The only reason this is a serious issue with people who have less hockey IQ is that this happenned to a Montreal player. If Chara wanted to, this player would be dead. His complete focus was to hit and rub the other player out. Not to break the guys neck. I have seen way worse hits this year. I dont even see a suspension being just here. I do seeing the rink designs being changed and should be changed.

    If you suspend Chara for this, basically the NHL is suspending someone for being bigger and stronger than his competition, while doing his job.

  • stevezie

    Yeah! If we can agree that it’s impossible to know Chara’s intentions, then what exactly are we seeking to eliminate? Rubbing people out? It wasn’t even a hard hit, it was just at an unfortunate location. Couldn’t this problem be solved by altering the specs of that location?
    Well that opinion makes for a lousy headline, so Air Canada, Parliment, TSN and the Montreal Police are going to go another way. I think Canucks Assistant coash Rick Bowness said it best: “It was terrible, but if this happened fifteen years ago I’m not sure that there’s any outcry at all*.”

    *Not exact quote.

  • stevezie

    late to the converstion but………..

    If this is how Air Canda feels about our national sport I would request them to take the Canada out of their name because their level of air transport service is an embarrassment to the Canadian identity!!

  • oildawg99

    New to the Nation.

    Anyone else getting annoyed with people who watch a play in super slow motion and are able to see inside a players brain to know what they are thinking?
    If Chara did this with intention and it was so easy to do we would see a lot more of it in the NHL. There really are not that many cases of guys getting there heads run into the turnbuckle. Reason: it is pretty friggen hard to do at full speed.

    There may be an argument for a couple of games because it was interference so a player was hurt on an illegal hit… but to say he did it on purpose is beyond stupid.

  • Dominoiler

    late to the party, but…

    What are you smoking gregor?..

    “It was seven years ago this past Tuesday that Todd Bertuzzi jumped Steve Moore and the reaction wasn’t close to the emotional outcry that we are witnessing right now.”

  • Dominoiler

    “Anyone else getting annoyed with people who watch a play in super slow motion and are able to see inside a players brain to know what they are thinking?”

    – yup

    “but to say he did it on purpose is beyond stupid.”

    – Glad to see that at least ‘you’ can see inside his brain with the slow motion.. just so you know, your argument is just as stupid..

    “If Chara did this with intention and it was so easy to do we would see a lot more of it in the NHL.”

    – every player is a dirt bag?.. has no respect.. you could be right?!..

    “There really are not that many cases of guys getting there heads run into the turnbuckle. Reason: it is pretty friggen hard to do at full speed.”

    – it helps if you push the other player into it.. In fact, it is much more likely if you are being directed into it.. without that helping hand.. well.. it doesnt happen..

    Just cus it doesnt happen often and its unlikely to occur doesnt mean that chara didnt do it with intention..

  • Hungoverman

    To the guys who say Chara didn’t know where he was on the ice:

    “I’ll tell you this: if you say that you don’t know where things are around the ice, I think you’re not telling the truth,” Henrik Sedin said. “You play the game for 20 years, you know it’s there.”

    Intent is not the issue. Accountability for knowing where you are on the ice and the potential consequences of your actions is.

    Sedin agrees: “It’s gotten to the point, you have to suspend guys if you hit the head. You have to do it even if guys say they didn’t mean to do it or it’s an accident. You have to start somewhere.”

    • Quicksilver ballet

      Agree 100%

      It’s an impossible thing to prove but Chara knew exactly what he was doing. Only Zdeno himself knows if he got away with one. I thought that same thing the moment i seen the replay. It doesn’t matter he played the game for 13 yrs without any blemishes on his record, he chose the selfish route on this and “evened” things up from his side of the fence. Don’t care about restitution in incidents like this, as far as i’m concerned the more blood in hockey the better. These guys are well taken care of when injuries occur. Attention and interest in hockey spike considerably when incidents like this hit the big time.

  • oildawg99

    Some of the posters here should probably be advocating for an attempted murder charge as anyone knows pushing someones head into the turnbuckle at that speed on purpose could result in death. But I guess that goes for anyone who body checks anyone on the ice… maybe we should start throwing all defenseman who try to not give a player a direct line to the puck by squeezing them out in jail for a length of time…that will teach them…or is it just when they hit Canadiens?

    What about when the Mac Truck knocked out Ivanans earlier this year… how about assault…attempted murder? Shouldn’t Mac know that one of his punches could actually kill someone?

    Great job on this article as it shows how people can have a knee jerk reaction to a situation with little basis on facts.

    Maybe the NHL should have given him a couple games just to appease the people who are getting too excited about this. If Chara has been the type of player as some suggest with no respect for the game who goes around trying to injure people don’t you think there would be a lot more injured people…this man is a beast.

    And please don’t compare this to the bertuzzi incident as they are not even close in comparison.