Realistic Expectations: Troy Brouwer

Sergei Belski/USA TODAY Sports

When the Calgary Flames signed Troy Brouwer, the intention was obvious: acquire a veteran right winger who can score. Jiri Hudler, he is not; Hudler actually had more points in 2015-16, even though that season was regarded as not as great for him.

But Brouwer provides a much more physical presence. He hits, he mucks it up in the crease, he’s like five inches taller and 30 pounds heavier. It was time to move on, and the Flames found the player they wanted to do just that with.

Brouwer will be a Flame for the next four years, assuming no trades or expansion draft shenanigans. He’ll be one of the higher-paid forwards on the team throughout that time. Let’s just focus in on year one for now.

The season before

Brouwer only spent one year in St. Louis, acquired in exchange for T.J. Oshie. There, he scored 18 goals and 39 points, playing mostly with Paul Stastny, David Backes, and Robby Fabbri. The cool thing about this in particular is that he spent a lot of time alongside Fabbri, a rookie centre who put up 37 points last season and hey there’s some matchup with Sam Bennett there, isn’t there?

The last time Brouwer failed to come anywhere near the 20-goal mark was his own rookie season in 2008-09, when he scored 10; since then, he’s ranged from 17-25 goals a year. He scored 26 points as a rookie; after then, his worst years were two 33-point years for the Washington Capitals, though it has to be noted that one of them came during the lockout season. Otherwise, his lowest totals have been 36 or 39 points.

So would it be fair to expect 20 goals and 40 points out of Brouwer this year? Probably.

Brouwer averaged 16:59 in ice time for the Blues last season, which was sixth out of all forwards on the team. His .48 points per game was seventh among regular Blues forwards. He played 147:48 on the powerplay, fifth among all Blues forwards; he scored 10 points on the man advantage, also fifth among all Blues forwards. (Though seven of those points were goals – third amongst the Blues forward group.) On the penalty kill, he was the third-most used forward, with 122:21 in ice time.

In short: last year, in St. Louis, Brouwer was on the fringe of being a top six forward, but he was used frequently in all situations and scored enough to justify it. However, via Own The Puck, the fancier numbers aren’t kind to him at all, and suggest that with the Blues he was more of a glorified third liner than anything else.

Story 1


The Flames really don’t have much in the way of wingers. They have Johnny Gaudreau, they have Michael Frolik, they have Matthew Tkachuk, apparently, who’s 18 years old and might not even play the full year in the NHL. Then there’s the hope Hunter Shinkaruk or Micheal Ferland do something positive and stick and… that’s pretty much it.

So Brouwer is, by default, one of the Flames’ top wingers. He’ll get a lot of ice time in all situations, so expecting at least 40 points out of him is entirely justifiable. The most he’s ever averaged in a season was 18:51 a game in 2013-14, when he scored his career high of 43 points for the first time; wanting that much out of him again is entirely realistic.

Then there’s this factoid: last season, the Blues used him primarily in a defensive capacity. Via Corsica


Brouwer wasn’t as great at the whole defensive thing as a couple of his teammates around the area – both David Backes and Patrik Berglund put up better possession numbers in pretty similar circumstances – but Brouwer probably won’t be used in a defensive role this season.

With two kids in Tkachuk and Bennett likely starting on his line, Brouwer should be the beneficiary of more offensive zone starts. Perhaps the 2014-15 season is a good one to look at for him, when he had an OZS of 35.01%. That was his second 43-point year, not to mention a 50.83% 5v5 CF season (albeit -0.61 CF% rel).

If the Flames get the 2014-15 version of Brouwer, they’ll probably be happy with him for the 2016-17 season. After that will remain to be seen; after all, he’s 31 years old already, and time eventually slows us all down. But for this season, at least, we should expect a competent top six winger that will help along some of the kids.

FlamesNation and Auto Canada want to give you a $10,000 NHL experience for four in Las Vegas! Enter your fantasy hockey team for FREE at and compete against readers across the Nation Network for your chance to win. Just pick your players from each draft box and make weekly trades to better your chances. Enter your team now at

  • Greatsave

    It was time to move on, and the Flames found the player they wanted to do just that with.

    So… not only does Troy feast on rebounds… he is the rebound??

  • jakethesnail

    Tre better spend his thanksgiving weekend finalizing a contract with Johnny Gaudreau so that the Flames Fans can give Thanks! Not Thanksgiving in the USA so Johnny can fly back to Calgary with Tre, the sooner the better!

  • Baalzamon

    Brouwer should be fine. He’s overpaid, but he’s still a useful player and it seemed he had a little chemistry going with Bennett. His mid-range shot, in particular, is terrifying.

  • freethe flames

    Stockton Heat wins 3-2 in first exhibition game. Janko with the Hat Trick, Gilles with the win. Poirier, Kylington, and Frattin with Assists. Mangiapane/Janko/Frattin as a line. 3 stars Janko/Poireir/Gilles.

  • RedMan

    “…with the Blues he was more of a glorified third liner than anything else.”

    you actually refer to a perennial 20 goal scorer as a “glorified 3rd liner”????

    so, please help me understand? is averaging 20 goals per year, without missing any games year after year, the average for 3rd liners?

    seriously, i’d like to know if any of you know where to find the stat – what is the average goal production for 3rd liners? where can a guy even find that out? that’s a “fancy stat” I’d like to hear, since we paid so much for a glorified 3rd liner.

    • Kevin R

      Agreed. The initial hate for Brouwer is baffling. Not sure what it will take to convince other, but with Johhny missing all of camp, Monahan too coming off injury & no chance of finding that RW for their line, we may be seeing the Bennett Tkachuk Brouwer line carrying the offensive production out of the gate.