Photo Credit: Brace Hemmelgarn-USA TODAY Sports

Flames’ roster already appears improved in early offseason overhaul

Standing idly by was not an option for the Flames this offseason; not after they set expectations for 2017-18 and failed spectacularly to meet them. The team’s faults became increasingly apparent as the season went on, leaving the Flames with really only one choice: big changes would have to come before October.

Mere days into the official start of the 2018-19 season, the Flames appeared to have already done just that.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The prototypical lineup for the Flames through 2017-18 often looked something like this:

Gaudreau Monahan Ferland
Tkachuk Backlund Frolik
Bennett Jankowski Hathaway
Brouwer Stajan Lazar
Giordano Hamilton
Brodie Hamonic
Kulak Stone

Only a small handful of forwards were particularly great. The good news is that they were mostly younger guys: Johnny Gaudreau, Sean Monahan, Matthew Tkachuk. Otherwise, the Flames were relying on everyone to have a career year. The depth was dependent on both Micheal Ferland and Sam Bennett proving they were the real deals; they did not. When the top players inevitably cooled off – or required four surgeries, such as Monahan – there was nobody capable of stepping up. Season over.

The depth was supposed to be in the defence; it failed to live up to expectations. The top pairing did a great job, but TJ Brodie floundered throughout the year, Travis Hamonic required an extensive adjustment period to playing in the west, and Michael Stone is still making $3.5 million in a bottom pairing role while being the team’s worst regular defender for some reason.

The Flames have been struggling to find consistency at the goaltending position for years, and this past season was no different. Mike Smith started out so great the Flames saw it fit to play the then-35-year-old every single night, leaving no chance for any backup to find his footing, forcing the team to eventually turn to an untested rookie. Then the then-35-year-old playing every single night got hurt, the untested rookie couldn’t handle being a starter, neither could the other untested rookie, and the season was really over.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Sure, injuries hurt the Flames. That forward depth looks a lot better with a healthy Jaromir Jagr in place for Garnet Hathaway, and a healthy Kris Versteeg dressing 70- or 80-something times instead of just 24. But injuries hurt every team, and the Flames weren’t prepared for it.

Now, compare last year to what the Flames may have to work with this season (so far):

Gaudreau Monahan Neal
Tkachuk Backlund Lindholm
Bennett Ryan Frolik
Czarnik Jankowski Brouwer
Giordano Brodie
Hanifin Hamonic
Kulak Stone

The Flames have focused almost exclusively on the forwards so far this offseason, and it looks like it’s paying off. Granted, we won’t know much until the puck actually drops, but both James Neal (even at his age) and Elias Lindholm are substantial upgrades on Ferland. Mark Jankowski will have to fight with Derek Ryan to get more minutes. Michael Frolik no longer has a guaranteed spot in the top six, and any justification for playing Hathaway every night is officially gone. Bennett could have Austin Czarnik – or any prospect who succeeds, really – nipping at his heels constantly. There’s more competition with a higher quality set of players, and more options when things just aren’t going right (more on that later).

In the immediate, the defence is a little worse. Noah Hanifin probably isn’t going to step in and replace Dougie Hamilton’s performance immediately; even Hamilton’s numbers in his first three years in the league beat out Hanifin’s. If Brodie is unable to return to form alongside Mark Giordano and Hanifin isn’t able to pull off a miracle of being beyond astounding right away, the Flames may have shot themselves in the foot. It’s a risk.

Goaltending is the exact same perilous adventure as it was last year, except this time around, both David Rittich and Jon Gillies have more NHL experience, which may help. On the other hand, Smith is another year older.

What’s left to do?

All that said, it’s hard to imagine the Flames are already done reshaping their roster, barring re-signing RFAs. The lineup looks better on paper, but as this past season showed us, one can never be too careful.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Is there a lot left to do at forward? Maybe the team could go after someone else, but that top six actually kind of looks like a real one now, and there’s still a chance for prospects who really impress at camp to work their way in there – though it may have to force some difficult decisions for management (i.e. waiving players who are worse, but already have a sunk cost attached to them).

The defence is still clogged. Assuming Dalton Prout is indeed the seventh defencemen, then there’s no room for prospects there at all, and the backend is likely where the Flames are most ready to plug somebody in. (What I’m getting at here is please make room for Rasmus Andersson. How can he not deserve it at this point. Please free him. And that’s assuming Juuso Valimaki doesn’t try to force his way on the team, too.)

And goaltending? Well, Bill Peters never had anything good to work with in Carolina. And goaltending is really the one position that can sink or swim an entire season singlehandedly like no other. There is a lot of cause to be anxious if the Flames don’t make any moves in net; while it could work out, is the current configuration a smart bet once again?


Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Founded in 1950, Sports Excellence Corporation represents over 150 family-owned independent hockey retailers across Canada and the United States. Our highly knowledgeable hockey specialists are available to assist all your equipment needs. Find your closest Sports Excellence retailer here: Find a location near you!

  • Mickey O'Reaves

    Treliving has got stones, I’ll give him that. The forward group is vastly improved, and has so many players that some of them have to get moved. There still has to be a move or two on the defence.

    The goaltending right now doesn’t look to get you far in the playoffs, but Treliving could be looking at upgrading and going for it already. BT has gone and stuck most of his chips in the middle again. He’s not afraid of risk if he thinks he’s right, but appears to really think things through .

    Thinking back to Treliving’s assessment of last season’s debacle, one little phrase stuck out. Treliving and Peters want players that, “aren’t intimidated.” Like when the stuff hits the proverbial fan, what’ve you got in ya. The player that came to mind for me right away was T.J. Brodie. He can easily be intimidated.

    There are more moves to be made, and it is fascinating to see what he’s got planned next. Let’s rock!

    • Honkydonk

      No one needs to be moved. With exception we always hope Brouwer is moved.

      Don’t forget injuries. You need fluidity in transitions for injuries etc. We forget we lost Frolik for a month? Versteeg for 60 games? Hamonic for 8 games? Chucky for 6 games? Mony could have missed 20 games but played thru it.

      Point is we will have injuries you need to account for. You need to maintain consistency in games won and when you are thin that’s impossible.

    • everton fc

      The Leafs want to dump Matt Martin. If they’d include Pickard, and maybe Kapanen, in some sort of deal that doesn’t impale us defensively, as they look very porous on the backend…

      I like Pickard.

      • Baalzamon

        The Flames can’t take on cap. They still need to re-sign Hanifin and Lindholm, and next summer need to extend Tkachuk and Bennett.

        The Flames need to move out salary, not take it on.

        • everton fc


          And so do the Leafs. This year, and next. They’d have to eat some of Martin’s, and really don’t need both Sparks and Pickard. If anything, moving Stone (who is not any better really, than who they currently have, and Hainsey has a NMC, I think), would be really a dump, both ways. I can’t see the Leafs wanting/needing Rittich, nor would I move Rittich, whose days is coming, I think, to prove he’s a valid #2 here. But Kapanen may be “had”, if the Leafs are somewhat desperate, cap-wise.

      • Parallex

        No thank you. Martin is terrible and overpaid, Pickard isn’t any better then Rittich/Gillies, and Kapanen has’t produced in the NHL so he might just be a tweener.

        I don’t want the Maple Leafs garbage unless it’s for our garbage. For that package I would trade them Stone, Rittich, and Hathaway (which they would refuse… because our garbage is like their garbabge… AKA it’s garbage).

  • Off the wall

    Well I guess you could say that Treliving had a massive plan in place. He went to the draft with basically nothing and managed to pull off a trade that not only shocked us, but made us wonder where he was heading.

    If you read the comments from draft day until today, it has been a stark contrast in terms of comments. I’d say overall it’s been a blast to watch the dominos fall and the comments become positive.

    Now we’re all speculating possibilities about lineups. I love it. We’re all engaged and excited!

    If any were doubting Treliving prior to the draft, I hope that you can at least give credit where credit is due.

    Treliving is invested heavily in our Flames. You don’t make a trip to Michigan with Rebar in tow, just to sign Czarnik, unless you’ve done your homework.

    That’s just one example!

    He’s already 3 steps ahead of us. Him and Peters’ are reshaping this team. I love Mickey’s O’Reeves ( great handle) term of Treepete.
    Sorry if I misspelled it Mickey.
    Don’t pummel me!

    Speaking of tandems… Treliving and Peters’ make a pretty good tandem!

  • rusty_shakleforde

    I’m super glad for the competition this will bring. I would hate to see Janko on the forth line, but this will be a good challenge for him. I think he can do it.

  • The Beej

    What is all this talk on here about moving forwards (frolik, jankowski)?

    We finally have some depth in the event of injuries. Lets not piss that away. When Jagr and and Versteeg went down last year our options were pretty limited.

    We dont need the cap space. See Ryans article from yesterday.

    If anything it is defense (stone) gets moved because Anderson has earned a spot.

    As it is now we can do something simple like put Lazar on waivers if we need to. As it is now our lineup has balance and options. And we can still fit in a prospect while still keeping things competitive.

    Gaudreau monahan Neal
    Tkachuk Backlund Lindholm
    Bennett Jankowski Frolik
    Mangiapane Ryan Czarnik

    Brouwer and Lazar as extras. Perhaps Hathaway and Lazar battle for that final spot. Foo and Czarnik battle for a roster spot. With Frolik on the 3rd line Bennett and Jankowski get a steady vet to work with.

    Tinker with the lineup i proposed as you see fit. We have options and pieces can be moved around. But if you start moving players out and we run into injuries then we are screwed again.

    We finally have a bit of depth. Why do some of you want to undo that?

    Maybe next summer when we know more about what we have in Phillips Dube Mangiapane and Foo, then sure move Frolik and buyout Brouwer if things are looking good. But for now we have a really good balance here of vets and youth. And now we arent forced to play Brouwer up the lineup. We have other options.

    • Loud_voices

      You are crazy if you think brouwer isn’t going to be in the lineup. I heard Bill Peters talking about how much he respects Brouwer. And a guy getting paid that much to warm the bench looks pretty stupid in the worlds eyes. Not to mention hes a good gritty player. And hes only as good as the team around him. He was 12th on the team in points this year with only 3 players above him that get paid less and 2 out of 3 of them (bennett and ferland) got all the chances in the world to play on the top line and with our best players, as brouwer basically got consistently different teammates all season long filling in for injuries with barely any time to develop true chemistry until a little near the end. So dont count brouwer out and look for a rebound season this year with more talent to solidify a lineup. And im not saying brouwer didnt get any chances with good players this year but Brouwer played consistenly with the least skilled players on calgary like bennett, stewart, Shore, stajan, and lazar.

    • Bawcos

      Agree Beej, Finally they have depth. I’m even willing to put the $5.75M Neal on the 3rd line for now. But BT missed by not trading Stone(as of yet). Always thought that was the first order of business – Must Move Stone!