Bottom line in Hamilton trade is this: Does it make the team better?

The real story may never be fully told.

Those “things” Flames GM Brad Treliving said he’s going to keep internal rather than share in the aftermath of trading away one of the best offensive defencemen in the league on Saturday have been talked about ad nauseam for months already.

A lack of interest in bonding with the boys. An irksome acceptance of the outcome of games. A conspicuous absence at the end-of-year exit interviews (with the media, and perhaps, with the brass, too).

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Dougie Hamilton’s personality wasn’t part of the fabric of the dressing room. He wasn’t happy here. There’s no denying that.

Dougie is different. There’s no way he should be demonized for that, but the bottom line is the team didn’t believe the many contributions they received offensively over three years as a member of the Flames were helping them move toward their ultimate goal — so they moved on.

We knew it was coming. It may not have played out exactly as myself and others predicted in the days following the disastrous end to the regular season, but it’s not far off.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The bottom line moving forward should be whether or not the blockbuster move makes the Flames better.

Treliving believes it does. Only time will tell.

Numbers on the ice don’t necessarily support that theory, as Ari Yanover brilliantly broke down for Flames Nation in a piece formed separately from emotion.

But the reason the NHL is so damn sensational as a league is how excruciatingly complex it is. The numbers never tell the whole story, as incredibly meaningful and illustrative as statistics have become.

So you have to ask yourself — until the evidence produces the undisputable verdict many months from now — do you believe the Flames a better team following the departure of Hamilton, winger Micheal Ferland and highly-touted prospect Adam Fox in return for forward Elias Lindholm and defenceman Noah Hanifin?

It should probably be broken down into two categories: immediately, and a year or two down the road.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Those 17 goals and 40-plus points from Hamilton on the backend will sure be missed. Unless, of course, TJ Brodie can get back to the 40-point plateau after two years of diminishing returns following his separation from Mark Giordano and a move to the left side.

Since he netted 17 goals and 86 points during the two years he spent the majority of his time with the Flames captain, let’s give him the benefit of the doubt that he has a bounce-back campaign on Gio’s right side in 2018-19.

Even if he only moderately improves, let’s not forget what that change should do to improve the second pairing, which was pitiful for most of last year with Brodie on the left and Travis Hamonic to his right.

The 21-year-old Hanifin started in the league as an 18-year-old three seasons ago and has improved every year with the Hurricanes. If he only produces as much as he did last year, and Brodie improves his own numbers, the Flames won’t feel much of a loss offensively — without taking into consideration what effect the Lindholm addition will have up front.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

So in the immediate, the Flames should have a more balanced backend if a little less dynamic.

In the long run, the upside of Hanifin is tremendous. He and Hamonic could prove to be the team’s top pairing another year from now. Hanifin instantly becomes part of the nucleus of a blueline group that has some exciting prospects looking likely to join him in the near future, with Rasmus Andersson set to crack the lineup as a regular on the right side, and both Juuso Valimaki and Oliver Kylington boasting significant offensive skill on the left at the WHL and AHL levels, respectively.

But let’s not dismiss the talents of the veteran Giordano just yet either. The kind of shape he keeps himself in, and the relatively low number of NHL games he’s played because of his foray into Russia, might suggest he’s one of the rare exceptions to the diminishing return of players in their mid-to-late 30s.

Up front, the team will miss Ferland … well, at least the 2015 first-round playoff version of him … or the first half of last season version.

And as effective as those two versions were, even they were very different from each other. He was far from physical for most of this season a couple of years removed from punishing the Vancouver Canucks in the postseason.

His inconsistency last year came after he’d finally established himself as a potentially elite winger on the top line with Johnny Gaudreau and Sean Monahan. His 40-goal pace stagnated and he wound up with 21 after scoring all but two of them before the all-star break.

Is Lindholm an instant upgrade?

At worst, the 23-year-old should put up as many points as Ferland. If he meshes with Johnny Hockey and Monahan, he could be in for a big jump from the 16 goals and 44 points he posted while playing with a revolving door of partners like Jordan Staal or Phillip Di Guiseppe and Sebastian Aho.

Again, he’s younger and quicker and more defensively responsible than Ferland, who will be an unrestricted free agent at the end of next season.

The long play is nearly as big a part of the picture for Treliving as the immediate need to shake up his dressing room chemistry (which, by the way, should be helped by the relationships between Hanifin, Gaudreau and Matthew Tkachuk, as well as Lindholm’s familiarity with fellow Swede Mikael Backlund).

He added two players with considerable NHL experience and success in spite of the fact they are in their early 20s, while parting ways with an unhappy star who had three more years on a deal but little interest in being here for them, a frustrating top line fill-in set to become a UFA a year and a few days from now, and a prospect who they knew was unlikely to sign with them following college — something they knew would hurt his trade value another year from now as that became more publicly clear after his junior year at Harvard.

With both Hanifin and Lindholm currently restricted free agents looking for new deals, their contracts become another massive piece of the future judgement on whether or not this trade was a successful one for the Flames.

You can bet that’s where Treliving is focusing his efforts now.


Founded in 1950, Sports Excellence Corporation represents over 150 family-owned independent hockey retailers across Canada and the United States. Our highly knowledgeable hockey specialists are available to assist all your equipment needs. Find your closest Sports Excellence retailer here: Find a location near you!

  • JoelOttosJock

    Mrazek is not being qualified by the Flyers, making him a ufa. Would look good in a flames uniform. Would give a much needed insurance policy over Smith.

  • Chucky

    Based on the fact that the Flames made this trade, it is no stretch to believe that the Flames have been shopping Hamilton since the end of the season. It is also not hard to believe that this was the best offer because giving up on Fox and losing Ferland must have been a tough pill to swallow.
    With Hamilton’s offensive productivity the only reasonable conclusion is that he is a toxic asset. The Flames have a strong on ice leadership group and they could not get Hamilton on side with the rest of the team so any team that has a playoff hope would not be interested. His reaction to the trip on Smith that could labeled the Bennett Manson fight cost the Flames at least 16 potential trade partners.
    Hamilton will go to Carolina, score a bunch of goals and sell some tickets, if Carolina gets to the point where they can contend then they will send him to another team that does not need team players. Teams win championships not individual players and he does not seem to be part of a team.

  • TheWheeze

    Lets’ go to the subject of Bennett, a favorite topic amongst
    FN. My personal belief is they know what they have in Bennett, and are going to give him every chance to succeed, especially given proper coaching. We all know how GG was on a personal level with his players. That much was obvious. His complete lack of any kind of emotion on the bench told the story.

  • Fat Tony

    Johnny – Mony – Lindholm
    Bennett – Janko – Tkachuck
    Mangiapane – Backlund – Frolik
    Lazar/Brouwer – Shore – Dube/Foo

    Gio – Brodie
    Hanifin – Hamonic
    Kulak – Rass/Stone


    Given that there are no more trades or signings I figure this is the closest representation of what the lineup could or would look like. I would like to see Stone moved for a salary dump, perhaps Ottawa would take him to keep Mark happy, however, I would like to see the bottom D pairing as Kylington – Rass with Kulak as the 7th.
    Any thoughts??

    • BlueMoonNigel

      Bennett has not earned second line status, and there is no scoring from your 4th line. Third line scares me too as two of the guys are in need of bounce-back seasons and the other is unproven. Is tying Mang to a couple of defensive-first guys really the best way to take advantage of his assets?

      I see goals scoring from your forward group very hard to come by.

      Defensive pairings are as advertised, but a question. At this time last year, Flames’ fans gushed at the thought of the Hamonic-Brodie pairing. Looked great on paper but it was an absolute train wreck on the ice. What happens if Hanifin and Hamonic are a repeat of Brodie and Hamonic?

      • Redleader

        I think Brodie should get moved out two , he just doesn’t have the courage and drive , if Hamilton is gone for not showing Heart on the ice , I suppose Brodie’s value is two low right now, maybe they try boosting Brodie’s value with Gio to start season .

  • TheWheeze

    We will never know for sure, but I am wondering if this was the best offer the Flames got for Hamilton, or if Treliving was simply focused on making a deal for players his new coach was familiar with. Follows the pattern, new coach – players from his old team seem to follow.