Defending Jay Feaster
When Jay Feaster officially replaced Darryl Sutter as the General Manager of the Calgary Flames in the December of 2010, a collective sigh of relief echoed through Calgary . After all, Sutter’s dubious moves were jeopardizing the already down ward spiralling and aging Flames team – one no trade clause at a time.
That feeling of relief, was then quickly substituted by a (possibly pre-mature) sense of optimism. After all, Feaster was at the helm of the Tampa Bay Lightning when they beat out the Flames for the Stanley Cup in ’04. What many people didn’t know is that Feaster inherited most of the cup winning core. Richards, Lecavalier, Khabibulin, St. Louis and many others were already there when Feaster assumed the commanding role. Yes, he augmented the key pieces with a few additions (namely Daryl Sydor and Ruslan Fedotenko) that were imperative in the Lightning’s run to the Stanley Cup Final, but the point is most of the heavy lifting had been done prior to his arrival.
So all the praise and hoopla he earned following the Cup win wasn’t all that warranted.
One word I used to describe him when he was named the Interim GM here in Calgary : overrated. Besides his minimal involvement in crafting that one championship team in Tampa , he also carried with him an abysmal drafting record with the Bolts. Excluding the Steven Stamkos pick for obvious reasons, only 4 players drafted under Feaster went on to play over 150 NHL games – none of them becoming more than role/replacement players once reaching the NHL. He did draft Karri Ramo though, so let’s hope he hit that one out of the park.
Nonetheless, optimism ran high in Calgary that Jay Feaster would be the man to right the ship and take the Flames to the promised land.
House on Fire
Unfortunately, that hasn’t been the case. When Feaster was promoted to the GM role, he was faced with two problems: An unreasonable pressure o win and an aging, sub par, over paid roster. He had a truck load of no-trade clauses to deal and barely any cap space to operate with.
If Feater tried to look to the prospect system for help, he’d be met by only Greg Nemisz, Tim Erixon and Leland Irving. Everything was pretty bleak. He slowly began to cleanse the organization of these trouble spots and mend the tears that Darryl Sutter’s madness had created. He also had to do this with the intention of staying competitive and making the playoffs – which has proved to be an impossible task.
Slowly, the prospect system has been rebuilt and cap flexibility has been restored. Yet, a portion of the fan base is still unhappy. Patience has seemingly run out and people want a change. But why? What has Feaster done to merit a pink slip? As my colleague here at FlamesNation Ryan Pike once wisely said, "Feaster inherited a house on fire, put it out and is now taking heat because the house is slightly charred." I couldn’t agree more.
All Feaster has done in Calgary is clean up the mess that Sutter left behind and only now is beginning to put his own stamp on the club. My opinion is probably in the minority when I say this but I think Feaster has done an admirable job considering the circumstances.
The Feaster Resume
Trades:
Note: The players acquired by the Flames will be first and both bolded and italicized
Trade: | Date: | Verdict: |
Freddy Modin for 2011 7th round pick (#193-Colin Blackwell) | February 28, 2011 | Not the best trade as Modin was plagued by injury and only ended up playing 4 games for |
Roman Horak, 2011 2nd round pick (#45-Markus Granlund), 2011 2nd round pick (#57-Tyler Wotherspoon) for Tim Erixon, 2011 5th round pick (#133-Shane McColgan) | June 1, 2011 | After being handcuffed by Erixon’s refusal to sign with |
Chris Butler and Paul Byron for Ales Kotalik Robyn Regehr 2012 2nd round pick (#44 – Jake McCabe) | June 25, 2011 | I don’t really want to talk about this. Feaster got fleeced, plain and simple. |
Jordan Henry for Keith Seabrook | July 9, 2011 | AHLer for AHLer. No real winner or loser here, although Henry did put in good minutes for the Heat during his time there. |
Pierre-Luc Letourneau-Leblond for a 2012 5th round draft pick (#135 – Graham Black) | Stupid move and Black has put up back to back 50 point seasons in the WHL. This could come back and bite | |
Lee Stempniak for Daymond Langkow | August 29, 2011 | Langkow was coming off that gruesome neck injury and was in the twilight of his career anyway. Stempniak is a big part of this Flames team right now and has turned in good value for the Flames. Win for |
Blair Jones for Brendan Mikkelson | January 6, 2012 | Low upside prospect for low upside prospect. I actually thought Jones was filling in that 4th line center role well this year, but the coaching staff seem to agree. Mikkelson also got some NHL games under his bet with the Lightning but has since moved on. I’d call this deal a draw. |
Michael Cammalleri, Karri Ramo, 2012 5th round pick (Brett Kulak) for Rene Bourque, Patrick Holland, 2013 2nd round pick (#36 – Zach Fucale) | January 12, 2012 | The winner of this deal will ultimately be decided by the prospects involved. Cammalleri and Bourque have brought relatively the same value to their respective teams, it all lies on what Holland/Fucale and Kulak/Ramo do. At this point, I’d call it a draw but Ramo’s performance this season will likely decide it. |
Brian Connelly for Brendan Morrison | January 27, 2012 | Another low key move, the Flames traded Morrison who no longer had a spot on the team to |
Akim Aliu for John Negrin | January 30, 2012 | This deal looked a lot better for |
2012 1st round pick (#21-Mark Jankowski) 2012 2nd round pick (#42-Patrick Sieloff) for 2012 1st round pick (#14-Zemgus Girgensons) | June 22, 2012 | The infamous Jankowski deal that made some Flames fan cringe – when the trade was announced as well as when the 21st pick was made. After all, Finnish dynamo Tuevo Teravainen (projected to go Top 5) was still on the board and Jankowski was projected to go mid 2nd. But now when looking at this deal – Jankowski and Sieloff for Girgensons – it’s a win for the Flames. Girgensons doesn’t project to be anything above a fringe second line guy while Jankowski could be a Top 6 center and Sieloff a Top 4 defenseman. |
Dennis Wideman for Jordan Henry and a 2013 5th round pick | June 27, 2012 | That’s about market value for the rights of a good NHLer like Wideman so nothing to complain about. Henry’s an AHL level guy and the 5th rounder was dealt. |
7th Round Pick (#198 – John Gilmour) for Henrik Karlsson | January 21, 2013 | Karlsson had no future in |
Mike Testwuide for Mitch Wahl | February 25, 2013 | AHLer for AHLer. Nothing to see here folks. |
Brian McGrattan for Joe Piskula | February 28, 2013 | Well not only did fan favourite Brian McGrattan add needed grit to the team, he also turned into a scoring machine, sniping 3 silky geno’s – matching his previous career total (LOL). Ryane Clowe had the same amount of goals as MacGrattan last year and the Rangers paid way more than an AHL defensemen to get him. Yeah, I’d rather have MacGrattan too. Who needs skating anyway? Career defining win for Feaster 😉 |
Ben Hanowski, Kenny Agostino and a 2013 1st Round Pick (#28 – Morgan Klimchuck) for Jarome Iginla | March 27, 2013 | We’re now wading into "wait and see" territory as these latest trades can’t be fairly judged for another few years. On the surface though, 2 solid prospects and Hanowski is pretty good return acknowledging the circumstances Iginla was traded in. Getting good return on an average 35 year old NHLer who will only go to ONE team is no easy task. Even if that guy is Jarome Iginla. Iginla is also no longer a member of the Penguins so those 3 pieces for 28 "eh" games of Iggy seems like good, bordering on great value for |
Mark Cundari, Reto Berra and a 2013 1st round pick (#22 – Emile Porier) for Jay Bouwmeester | April 1, 2013 | Wasn’t a fan of this deal when it happened and frankly, I’m still not one. Bouwmeester is still a premier NHL defensemen and albiet a little over paid, he’s worth more than what was acquired. It seemed like Feaster felt like he needed to tear it all down at once and may have rushed this deal a little. Best case scenario is that Berra is a starting goaltender, Cundari a Top 4 D and Porier a Top 6 forward but to me it looks more likely to turn into 3 average guys for Bouwmeester. Many media outlets however reported this was the only deal that included a 1st rounder – which would’ve been a must – so providing that be true, Feaster did ok. Again though, we can’t judge this trade fairly until we see what the three guys turn into. |
2013 5th Round Pick (#135 – Eric Roy) for Blake Comeau | April 3, 2013 | The fact that Feaster actually got something – let alone a solid prospect – out of a deal for Blake Comeau is magic. Tip of the hat to you sir. |
Corban Knight for a 2013 4th Round Pick (#97 – Michael Downing) | June 18, 2013 | As of right now, Corban Knight is one of the top prospects in the organization, he fills a massive need at center and most importantly, is better than Michael Downing. Things can however, change. Today, it’s a steal for |
David Jones and Shane O`Brien for Cory Sarich and Alex Tanguay | June 27, 2013 | We’ll have to see how these guys do with their respective teams in 2013/14 but on the surface, Calgary gets younger, faster and harder to play against (Sarich doesn’t add toughness from the press box) which are all things they identified as goals. Looks good to me. |
T.J. Galiardi for a 2015 4th Round Pick | July 2, 2013 | We won’t know the verdict of this one until long down the road but Galiardi is a serviceable NHLer with a little upside still remaining which more than can be said for most 4th Rounders. Still, this one is long from decided. |
Kris Russell for a 2014 5th Round Pick | July 5, 2013 | Same as Galiardi, Russell is a better player than most 5th rounders will become, but we’ll have to wait and see how it plays out. |
Signings
Then there was the curious case of Ryan O’Reilly. What a rollercoaster that was. It went from pure elation "omg we’re gonna get a franchise centerman for only a 1st and a 3rd and we’re gonna make the playoffs with him" to disappointment "damn they matched" to a mix of horror and relief "we could have given Colorado our 1st and 3rd and then lost the player on waivers?!?! Thank god they matched!".
Either of those two deals happening would probably result in Feaster losing his job. Imagine if both signings had happened, the franchise would’ve been in the worst spot of any NHL team in recent memory.
Feaster also managed to sign Curtis Glencross to incredible hometown discount with a cap hit of $2.55 million for another 2 years which currently seems too good to be true. He took a swing at Roman Cervenka and has taken heat for KHL sniper’s flop in Calgary , but it was a decent low risk, medium reward gambit for the Flames. In fact, I’d like to see more of these type of ventures – eventually one of these home run swings will connect.
Juri Hudler’s 4 years at 4 million per is another deal that could be a source for criticism because he’s now one of the highest paid players on the team and not really the sort of talent that is going to turn the ship around. Hudler performed well last year, though he may not last in town over the long term.
Draft
So his drafting record is the only tangible thing (short of the team’s performance) left to judge Feaster’s time in Calgary and we all now that there’s little here that speaks against Feaster and his management team. He’s done a masterful job of turning the prospect base into one of the best in the league. Nonetheless, let’s take a quick look:
#, Year | Name | Status/Potential |
13, 2011 | F Sven Baertschi | Top 6 NHLer with upside |
21, 2012 | F Mark Jankowski | Top 10 team prospect with Top 6 upside |
6, 2013 | F Sean Monahan | Top 2 team prospect with top line potential |
21, 2013 | F Emile Poirier | Top 10 team prospect with Top 6 potential |
28, 2013 | F Morgan Klimchuck | Top 10 team prospect with Top 6 potential |
45, 2011 | F Markus Granlund | Top 15 prospect with Top 6 potential |
57, 2011 | D Tyler Wotherspoon | Top 15 prospect with Top 4 potential |
42, 2012 | D Pat Sieloff | Top 15 prospect with Top 4 potential |
75, 2012 | G Jon Gillies | Top 10 prospect with starting potential |
67, 2013 | D Keegan Kanzig | Prospect with potential |
104, 2011 | F Johnny Gaudreau | Top 5 prospect with top line potential |
105, 2012 | D Brett Kulak | Top 20 prospect with Top 6 potential |
124, 2012 | D Ryan Culkin | Top 15 prospect with Top 4 potential |
135, 2013 | D Eric Roy | Top 15 prospect with Top 4 potential |
164, 2011 | G Laurent Brossoit | Top 15 prospect with starting potential |
165, 2012 | F Coda Gordan | Top 25 prospect with Top 9 potential |
157, 2013 | F Tim Harrison | Top 20 prospect with Top 9 potential |
186, 2012 | F Matt DeBlouw | Top 25 prospect with NHL potential |
187, 2013 | D Rushan Rafikov | Top 15 prospect with Top 4 potential |
198, 2013 | D John Gilmour | Top 25 prospect with NHL potential |
Overall, it’s a very solid group. A gecent mix of talent and depth. Looks like a number of these guys will actually be NHLers one day. Quite the change from the Sutter era.
Conclusion
Recent articles from Christian Roatis