It’s September and we have wrapped up our annual Top 20 Prospects countdown here at FlamesNation. Now all that’s left is to run down the ballots and provide some insights into just how we reached the rankings that we did.

The top 20

We operated with a pretty simple system: our panel was asked to rank the 31 eligible prospects from 1 to 20, with first place votes worth 20 points and 20th place worth 1 point. We tallied up the points to provide a ranking of the organization’s top youngsters.
We started with the no-votes and runners up.
Seven players – Spencer Foo, Ryan Lomberg, Rinat Valiev, Nick Schneider, Mitchell Mattson, Justin Kirkland and Andrew Nielsen  – all failed to make any of our top 20 lists.
Jon Gillies received two points, Luke Philp six, while Milos Roman (17 points) and Glenn Gawdin (18 points) just missed the top 20.
Here’s how the Top 20 shook out:
Rank
Prospect
Points
Juuso Valimaki
180
Dillon Dube
171
Jakob Pelletier
160
Matthew Phillips
153
Emilio Pettersen
140
Filip Sveningsson
109
Dmitry Zavgorodniy
105
Adam Ruzicka
99
Alexander Yelesin
98
Martin Pospisil
87
Ilya Nikolayev
86
Tyler Parsons
83
Eetu Tuulola
70
Dustin Wolf
68*
Demetrios Koumontzis
68*
Artyom Zagidulin
60
Carl-Johan Lerby
38
Linus Lindstrom
31
Josh Nodler
20
Lucas Feuk
19
(Wolf won the tiebreaker with Koumontzis by virtue of being on more ballots.)
There’s a pretty clear layering in the overall rankings, with a pretty clean top five. From there, there was a bit of clustering with Sveningsson/Zavgorodniy, Ruzicka/Yelesin, Parsons/Nikolayev/Pospisil and Koumontzis/Wolf/Tuulola.
Probably the biggest surprise jump up the list from last year’s was Sveningsson, who had a heck of a 2018-19 season and went from being more of a fringey project guy to potentially a core prospect for the team.
The Athletic’s Corey Pronman ranked the Flames 31st in the league in prospect depth. That’s fair, as basically every home-run, high-end prospect in their system is in the NHL – or knocking on the door in the cases of Valimaki and Dube. Everyone else has some question marks or limited sample sizes against high-end opposition, but the Flames have a pretty good amount of different types of gambles. They all don’t have to work out, just a couple of them.

Individual lists

Nine of us voted on lists this year. That means there are nine of us you get to disagree with.
Rank
Ryan
Mike
Christian T
Christian R
Bill
Karim
Nathan
Konnie
Ramina
1
Valimaki
Valimaki
Valimaki
Valimaki
Valimaki
Valimaki
Valimaki
Valimaki
Valimaki
2
Dube
Dube
Dube
Dube
Dube
Dube
Dube
Dube
Dube
3
Pelletier
Pelletier
Pelletier
Pelletier
Phillips
Pelletier
Pelletier
Pelletier
Phillips
4
Phillips
Pettersen
Phillips
Pettersen
Pelletier
Phillips
Phillips
Phillips
Pelletier
5
Zavgorodniy
Phillips
Pettersen
Phillips
Pettersen
Yelesin
Pettersen
Nikolayev
Pettersen
6
Sveningsson
Sveningsson
Sveningsson
Wolf
Ruzicka
Zagidulin
Sveningsson
Pettersen
Zavgorodniy
7
Pettersen
Ruzicka
Ruzicka
Nikolayev
Zavgorodniy
Parsons
Ruzicka
Yelesin
Sveningsson
8
Nikolayev
Pospisil
Pospisil
Pospisil
Parsons
Pettersen
Pospisil
Ruzicka
Ruzicka
9
Parsons
Zavgorodniy
Zavgorodniy
Ruzicka
Sveningsson
Sveningsson
Koumontzis
Tuulola
Pospisil
10
Yelesin
Yelesin
Yelesin
Sveningsson
Yelesin
Nikolayev
Parsons
Zavgorodniy
Yelesin
11
Lindstrom
Koumontzis
Koumontzis
Parsons
Koumontzis
Pospisil
Zavgorodniy
Roman
Koumontzis
12
Zagidulin
Tuulola
Lerby
Nodler
Wolf
Koumontzis
Tuulola
Wolf
Wolf
13
Tuulola
Lerby
Tuulola
Zavgorodniy
Zagidulin
Tuulola
Nikolayev
Zagidulin
Nikolayev
14
Lerby
Parsons
Parsons
Yelesin
Tuulola
Zavgorodniy
Wolf
Nodler
Tuulola
15
Feuk
Zagidulin
Zagidulin
Lindstrom
Nikolayev
Wolf
Yelesin
Pospisil
Lerby
16
Wolf
Nikolayev
Nikolayev
Koumontzis
Lindstrom
Roman
Zagidulin
Feuk
Parsons
17
Gawdin
Wolf
Wolf
Lerby
Pospisil
Ruzicka
Lerby
Parsons
Lindstrom
18
Pospisil
Lindstrom
Nodler
Zagidulin
Gawdin
Lindstrom
Gawdin
Philp
Gawdin
19
Koumontzis
Feuk
Gawdin
Tuulola
Roman
Feuk
Lindstrom
Gawdin
Philp
20
Philp
Nodler
Feuk
Feuk
Gillies
Gawdin
Feuk
Gillies
Feuk
Just about everyone had the same four or five players at the top of their lists, led by Valimaki (unanimous first) and Dube (unanimous second). From there, most of us had some combination of Pelletier, Phillips and Pettersen – though some of us had Pettersen a wee bit lower.
Other than that, two general trends:
  • We all had the new Russians – Nikolayev, Zagidulin and Yelesin – all over the place. Four of us had Nikolayev ranked the highest, but the placement has tons of variation.
  • Similarly, goalies were all over the place. Few of us had a goalie anywhere in our top 10 and we had a good amount of variation our top-ranked goalies: five had Parsons, three had Wolf, and one had Zagidulin.