The Gilmour trade turns 25

In the 1980s the Calgary Flames were a powerhouse. Driven by their desire to beat the Edmonton Oilers and win some post-season hardware, they eventually toppled their northern rivals and made two trips to the Stanley Cup Final.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

The 1990s weren’t nearly as kind to the Flames. Some of their troubles were due to the NHL’s economics, with the declining Canadian dollar leading to a rather drastic sell-off of talent as the decade progressed. But easily the biggest setback to the organization’s fortunes was self-inflicted.

Twenty-five years ago today, the Flames made one of the worst trades in the history of the National Hockey League when they traded away Doug Gilmour.

In the midst of a contract dispute with the club, Gilmour left the team on New Year’s Day 1992. The whole dispute stemmed from an arbitration award that he didn’t agree with, and it became abundantly clear that the relationship was fractured beyond repair. Gilmour likely wouldn’t come to terms with the Flames on an extension. Below .500 and in the midst of a season that would see them miss the playoffs for the first time in nearly 20 years, the Flames needed to make a move.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

A day after Gilmour walked out on the team, general manager Doug Risebrough and his old mentor Cliff Fletcher (in a new job as Toronto’s head honcho) combined on the largest trade in NHL history.

Going to Toronto:

  • Gilmour, 28, arguably Calgary’s best player and a 1989 Stanley Cup winner
  • Ric Nattress, 29, a big-bodied right-shot defender and a 1989 Stanley Cup winner
  • Jamie Macoun, 30, a responsible left-shot defender and a 1989 Stanley Cup winner
  • Rick Wamsley, 32, Calgary’s backup goalie and a 1989 Stanley Cup winner
  • Kent Manderville, 20, a two-time World Junior gold medalist and one of Calgary’s top prospects

Coming to Calgary:

  • Gary Leeman, 27, two years removed from a 50-goal season
  • Alex Godynyuk, 21, a fringe NHLer who had played 49 games before the trade
  • Michel Petit, 27, a depth defenseman with some offensive skill
  • Craig Berube, 26, a physical forward known best for his pugilism
  • Jeff Reese, 25, a backup goalie

Within 24 hours, families huddled around the sports page of the Calgary papers to find out what the Flames got back for Gilmour. Parents and children alike exclaimed that they’d never heard of any of the players acquired by Calgary. Many wondered why Risebrough didn’t just let Gilmour sit out and shop around for a better deal rather than immediately make a knee-jerk trade. 

Confusion and frustration abounded, and were compounded over the subsequent seasons as the five assets acquired from Toronto disappeared into the ether without being converted into anything else. In a tough situation (a holdout), Al Coates was able to convert Joe Nieuwendyk into Dallas’s top prospect (Jarome Iginla) and a solid depth forward (Corey Millen) and that foresight allowed the Flames to make subsequent moves. 

The lasting legacy of the Gilmour trade on the Calgary side was Jeff Reese’s three-assist game against San Jose in 1993 and very little else.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

  • supra steve

    Well thanks for bringing that up again.

    Leeman didn’t ever regain his scoring touch from a few years previous. Godynyuk’s most famous moment was getting caught shoplifting at World Junior tournament, again a few years previous. Loosing 2 solid D-men (particularly Macoun) added insult to the injury of the loss of Gilmour.

    A dark time for Flame fans.

  • NHL93

    Doug Risebrough was schooled by his master on that one. I remember at the time the media/Flames were trying to spin Godynyuk as a future franchise defenseman in the making. Ugh.

  • Kensington

    The owners forced the hand of Management as they went into huge cost cutting mode resulting in a panic trade which sent Calgary on a downward spiral for decades after. This trade was made by the team owners!

    • Kevin R

      Bunk! If Ownership didn’t want to pay salaries, a deal like that should have gotten close to 20 1st round picks back. Ok to give away your team but at least get something for the future. It was tough to stomach Nieuy & Fleury trades as well because of the dollar & cost cutting but at least they brought back Iginla & Regher. Like Supra Steve & Prendrefeu mentioned, this stuff should be left buried & never brought up on FN ever again. I don’t see Stock Brokers comensurating Black Friday.

  • BlueMoonNigel

    What I learned from this trade was that it has to be a pretty awful blunder a GM makes for him to never get another job in pro sports. Terrible as the trade was, Riser moved on from the Flames to executive positions with the Oilers and Wild. Pro sports management has got to be the most environmentally-conscious sector of society the way it is diligently recycles. The mileage they can get on a load of crap is astounding.