Ranking the Flames’ five best backup goaltending options for 2021–22

Photo credit:Kelvin Kuo-USA TODAY Sports
Mike Gould
2 years ago
The Calgary Flames need goaltending help.
31-year-old Jacob Markstrom is undeniably the team’s No. 1 option, with his $6 million contract and no-movement clause looming large over the Flames’ crease.
Right now, he’s also Calgary’s only option. The Flames currently have two goaltenders under contract and, with all due respect, Dustin Wolf isn’t ready to play in the NHL. In all likelihood, Wolf will be spending the entire 2021–22 season in the American Hockey League with the Stockton Heat.
Tyler Parsons isn’t the guy, either. He’ll be back — the Flames tendered him a qualifying offer on Monday — but he’s coming off a season where he appeared in just one professional game and allowed five goals on 25 shots. Parsons needs to play a lot of good games in the AHL before he’s looked at as a potential backup option behind Markstrom.
Unrestricted free agency is set to begin today. This period will likely give the Flames their best opportunity to identify and sign their backup goaltender for the 2021–22 season. Let’s take a look at some of the top candidates on the market.

Before we start, let’s cross some names off this list for a variety of reasons.
  • Tuukka Rask has been one of the NHL’s best starting goaltenders for much of his career and feels very ill-suited for a backup role. He’ll also want a ton of money and is probably not leaving Boston.
  • Philipp Grubauer is coming off a year where he appeared in 40 games for the Colorado Avalanche and went 30-9-7 with a .923 save percentage. Regardless of where he ultimately signs, he’ll be a starter. Calgary can’t offer him that opportunity.
  • Frederik Andersen had a very tough year in 2020–21 but he’s only 31 and he’ll likely want to land in a spot where he can prove himself as still being a starting goaltender capable of carrying a big workload.
  • Petr Mrazek missed much of the 2020–21 campaign due to injury but was lights-out in the 13 games he played, posting a 6-2-3 record and a .923 save percentage. The 29-year-old Czech netminder will likely be seeking a starting gig.
  • Linus Ullmark was one of the few bright spots on an atrocious Sabres team last season. Despite playing behind the league’s second-worst defence, the 27-year-old went 9-6-0 with a .917 save percentage. He’ll get a payday somewhere as a starter.
  • Brian Elliott, Carter Hutton, and Curtis McElhinney are all 35 or older and are coming off seasons where they posted save percentages in the .880s (or worse). It’s hard to see much upside with any of these options (and it also seems extremely unlikely Elliott would return).
  • Craig Anderson performed admirably in spot duty with the Washington Capitals this past season. He’s also 40 and might just retire. It’s hard to say but, given how little he played in 2020–21, he probably shouldn’t be atop the Flames’ list.

5. James Reimer

Reimer, 33, is one of the most experienced goaltenders on the market. With 384 NHL games under his belt with Toronto, San Jose, Florida, and Carolina, Reimer has travelled the continent many times over as a professional hockey player. He’s also found success in each of those markets.
After spending over a half-decade as the Maple Leafs’ de facto starter (not an easy task in the early 2010s), Reimer made it to the 2016 Stanley Cup Final with San Jose as Martin Jones’ backup. In eight regular-season games with the Sharks, Reimer went 6-2-0 with a .938 save percentage. Not bad.
Reimer signed a five-year deal with the Florida Panthers in July 2016 and played reasonably well in the first two seasons of the contract, posting .920 and .913 single-season save percentages. Along with Florida’s other three goaltenders (Roberto Luongo included), Reimer struggled mightily in 2018–19 and was dealt to the Hurricanes the following summer.
In 2019–20, Reimer posted one of the best seasons of his career. He combined a 14-6-2 record with a .914 save percentage and, according to Evolving-Hockey, 7.63 goals saved above expected (GSAx). Reimer played 22 games with the 2020–21 Hurricanes and took a slight step back, posting a .906 record and allowing 2.70 goals more than expected.
Reimer likely wouldn’t be too expensive and he’s capable of putting together extended stretches of excellent play. From a backup, that’s just about all a team can expect.

Failed to load video.

4. Jaroslav Halak

Halak is another goaltender who’s been around the block many times. Not including his brief stint with the Buffalo Sabres (he dressed as a backup for the team in 2014 but never played), Halak has suited up with the Montreal Canadiens, St. Louis Blues, Washington Capitals, New York Islanders, and Boston Bruins during his lengthy NHL career.
The 36-year-old Slovak netminder has 539 NHL games to his credit and an impressive .916 career save percentage. Dating back to 2007-08, Halak has posted a positive GSAx figure in 11 of his last 14 NHL seasons. He’s been a consistently excellent goaltender over a very long period of time.
After starting his tenure in Boston with seasons of .922 and .919 save percentages, Halak went 9-6-4 with a .905 in 2020–21. He also posted one of those three negative GSAx seasons, allowing 7.36 more goals than expected in just 19 games.
Halak has bounced back from worse seasons — he posted a -9.23 GSAx figure in his final season on Long Island before improving to +10.08 in his debut with Boston — but he’s also getting up there in years. He’s been connected to Vancouver in early reports.

Failed to load video.

3. Jonathan Bernier

Bernier is another ex-Leaf who has found success in many different markets around the league. The Los Angeles Kings selected Bernier with the 11th overall pick in the 2006 draft; he posted a .912 save percentage and a 29-20-6 record over parts of five seasons with the Kings before being traded to Toronto in 2013 for a collection of futures.
While fellow 2013 offseason acquisition David Clarkson struggled to find his game in Toronto, Bernier thrived in his debut go-round with the Leafs. He went 26-19-7 with a .922 save percentage and 8.31 GSAx. Bernier subsquently posted a .912 to go along with 2.32 GSAx in 2014–15 but struggled in 2015–16, allowing 11.87 more goals than expected (the third-worst mark in the NHL) in just 38 games.
Bernier’s tenure with the Leafs concluded unceremoniously when he was traded to the Anaheim Ducks in exchange for a “conditional draft pick” which ended up being literally nothing. Since 2016, Bernier has operated almost exclusively in a tandem or as a backup and has never come close to playing 55 games in a season (as he did in back-to-back years with the Leafs).
Most recently, Bernier appeared in 24 games with the abysmal 2020–21 Detroit Red Wings. The 32-year-old posted a 9-11-1 record and a .914 save percentage; his 1.80 GSAx figure ranked 21st among the NHL’s 92 goaltenders last season. Despite being traded to the Hurricanes last week as part of the Alex Nedeljkovic deal, Bernier is reportedly unlikely to sign in Carolina and is set to hit the market.

Failed to load video.

2. Laurent Brossoit

Brossoit, 28, has spent his entire NHL career in Canada. Prior to his three seasons with the Winnipeg Jets, Brossoit spent parts of five campaigns in Edmonton with the Oilers organization.
The Calgary Flames — yes, those Flames — drafted Brossoit in the sixth round of the 2011 NHL Entry Draft (exactly 60 spots later than Johnny Gaudreau). Then-GM Jay Feaster eventually included him as part of the 2013 trade with Edmonton which saw Ladislav Smid become a Flame.
Brossoit only played 28 games with the Oilers before signing a UFA deal with the Jets in 2018. He immediately emerged as the team’s go-to backup option behind Connor Hellebuyck, posting an impressive .925 save percentage and 10.89 GSAx in 21 games.
In 2020–21, Brossoit appeared in 14 games with Jets and went 6-6-0 with a .918 save percentage and 0.42 GSAx. He’s one of the youngest UFA goaltenders on the market and he appears to have potential upside as a tandem goaltender. If the Flames want to bring in a potential longer-term option to push Markstrom for starts, Brossoit might be their best bet.

Failed to load video.

Before we identify our top option, let’s take a look at some other likely backups who missed out on being included on this list.
  • David Rittich is only 28 and has obvious ties to the Flames, having spent parts of five seasons in the organization. He appeared in just 15 games with the team in 2020–21 before being traded to the Toronto Maple Leafs and likely would’ve played less had Markstrom remained healthy. Rittich told Sportsnet after the trade he “thought [Markstrom would] play a little more than me, but I didn’t think it would be that much more than me.” He’ll likely seek an opportunity on a team without a $6 million AAV goaltender.
  • Braden Holtby was just bought out of a two-year deal. That doesn’t happen very often but the move was understandable after a year where Holtby played just 21 games and allowed 8.61 more goals than expected. After back-to-back underwhelming years, Holtby will likely sign a cheap deal somewhere to rebuild his value. He’s only 31 but, given his recent struggles, he lacks some of the upside of the other names on this list.
  • Martin Jones was once a promising young goaltender who looked to have a stranglehold on the San Jose Sharks’ crease. Times change and the Sharks have bought out Jones following his third consecutive season with a dismal .896 save percentage. Like Holtby, the 31-year-old will probably sign a cheap one-year deal somewhere. Maybe Calgary takes a look at Jones — he did play for the Hitmen, after all — but his recent track record is simply not good enough to justify bringing him in as a goaltender to rely upon.
  • Devan Dubnyk combines the recent struggles of Holtby and Jones with the age of Elliott and Hutton. The 35-year-old has had a good career — with successful stints in Edmonton, Arizona, and Minnesota — but is no longer a safe bet to post a save percentage in the .915 range every season. Since the 2016–17 season, Dubnyk has surrendered a whopping 80.78 more goals than expected in 244 games. That’s simply not close to being good enough.

1. Antti Raanta

Raanta might be one of the most talented goaltenders on the market. He’s also dealt with numerous injuries during his tenure with the Arizona Coyotes and appeared in just 12 games last season. Still, the 32-year-old Finn is capable of playing at an elite level when he’s healthy.
One of the NHL’s premier backup goaltenders during his time in Chicago and New York, Raanta became a Coyote in 2017 as part of a deal which saw Tony DeAngelo (heard of him?) and a first-round pick head to the Rangers.
In his debut turn with the ‘Yotes, Raanta was nothing short of sensational. He managed a 21-17-6 record in 47 games with the club in 2017–18, posting an eye-popping .930 save percentage and ranking third in the entire NHL (behind John Gibson and Jonathan Quick) with 25.14 GSAx.
Injuries limited Raanta to just 12 games in 2018–19 but he returned in full force to help the Coyotes make the playoffs in 2019–20. In 33 games during the shortened season, Raanta went 15-14-3 with a .921 save percentage and ranked 13th in the NHL with 5.64 GSAx.
Raanta dealt with multiple injuries in 2020–21 and posted a .905 save percentage and -1.91 GSAx in a dozen games. If he’s looking to rebuild his value on a short-term contract, he could find a home in Calgary. The Flames certainly could use a backup option who is capable of providing bona fide top-tier goaltending if called upon.

Failed to load video.

2021 Flames UFA Targets

Tomas Tatar | Blake Coleman | Mikael Granlund | Zach Hyman | Jaden Schwartz | Taylor Hall | Alexander Edler | Non-tendered RFAs (Ritchie, Suter, etc.) | Jake McCabe

Check out these posts...